Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Alok Sharma criticises government's oil and gas bill

The bill, which garnered 293 votes for and 211 against, saw no opposition from Tory MPs, with Sharma choosing to abstain

Alok Sharma criticises government's oil and gas bill

Alok Sharma, former business secretary and president of the Cop26 climate talks, has voiced his concerns that the government's new oil and gas bill, which recently passed its second reading in the Commons on Monday (22), neither reduces household energy costs nor generates employment.

Instead, he argues, it contradicts the UK's commitment to phasing out fossil fuels, The Guardian reported.


The bill, which garnered 293 votes for and 211 against, saw no opposition from Tory MPs, with Sharma choosing to abstain. It mandates the North Sea Transition Authority to conduct annual calls for new offshore oil and gas license applications.

This move comes despite warnings from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, consisting of hundreds of experts, who have clearly stated that awarding new oil and gas licenses is incompatible with the goal of limiting global warming to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels.

Exceeding this threshold could lead to a climate disaster, adversely affecting the lives of millions.

Furthermore, this legislation seems to be at odds with the promises made by UK ministers at the previous year’s Cop28 conference in Dubai, where they committed to phasing out oil and gas production.

Addressing the inconsistency between the UK's climate commitments and current legislative actions, Sharma highlighted the contradiction in minister Graham Stuart's position at the Cop28 conference.

Sharma recalled Stuart's tweet from the conference, emphasising the need for an unabated phase-out of fossil fuels to achieve climate goals.

However, Sharma pointed out, the bill under consideration solely aims to increase oil and gas production licenses, a move he believes does not align with the commitment to transition away from fossil fuels.

Sharma expressed his skepticism about the bill's ability to reduce energy bills or create jobs, countering the assertions made by Energy Secretary Claire Coutinho.

He emphasised that the bill is intended to enhance domestic energy security, but raised concerns over the practical impact.

Sharma explained that the North Sea's oil and gas, owned by private companies, are not under government control regarding their sale, implying that this may not lead to lower energy bills.

He also highlighted the loss of 200,000 jobs in the oil and gas sector over the past decade, despite the issuance of hundreds of new drilling licenses, questioning the bill's potential for job creation.

Sharma further argued that the expertise and skills prevalent in the oil and gas sector could be effectively redirected towards renewable energy sources. He advocated for the government to shift its focus towards the development of more wind and solar power, as well as nuclear energy.

Ed Miliband highlighted that Sharma's criticism of the bill was echoed by several prominent Tories, including former net zero tsar Chris Skidmore, who resigned as an MP in protest of the government's plans, and former prime minister Theresa May.

The shadow energy secretary condemned the bill as "climate vandalism," addressing the Commons with a critique of its inadequacy.

“We face massive challenges as a country but it isn’t the scale of our problems that is apparent today, it’s the smallness of their response.” He said the bill was “risible” and ineffective in enhancing Britain's energy security.

However, Coutinho defended the bill, arguing that it would bolster energy security in both the UK and Europe. She acknowledged the practical constraints, stating, "We do not live in a world where we can simply turn off oil and gas." Coutinho highlighted the North Sea's resources, describing the UK as "blessed" for its access to these fossil fuels.

Some Tory MPs voiced reservations about the bill. Vicky Ford, representing Chelmsford, expressed concerns about the bill's global perception, suggesting, that by approving these licenses, the UK risks being seen as backing away from promises made on climate change.

Ford, alongside Jerome Mayhew, another member of the Conservative Environment Network, indicated their intent to support the bill initially, but planned to later endorse amendments aimed at compelling the UK's oil and gas sector to adopt more carbon-efficient practices.

May, known for signing net zero targets into law, was also speculated to oppose the bill. However, her absence from the Commons led to her abstaining from the vote.

Skidmore strongly opposed the bill, urging his former colleagues to reject it.

He said, “As I stated in my resignation letter, the future will judge harshly any MP that votes for new additional fossil fuels. Today’s legislation makes no economic sense, will deliver no additional energy security, and breaks the UK’s international commitments on climate action.”

Ami McCarthy, a political campaigner for Greenpeace UK, also criticised the government's decision, stating, though the government has secured a victory in this vote, it's a loss for the planet and all its inhabitants.

She said, “Literally no one benefits from this nonsensical, climate-wrecking bill except the oil and gas industry and its shareholders.”

Adding to the critique, Alasdair Johnstone from the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit remarked that the North Sea's oil and gas reserves are dwindling, and this bill merely distracts from genuine solutions for the UK's energy independence.

Johnstone said that the key to achieving UK's energy independence is to lessen the country's reliance on gas.

He suggested that the focus should be on developing renewable energy sources and enhancing insulation in homes, particularly those that are cold and damp.

He noted, however, that the government's performance in these critical areas has been a matter of some concern.

More For You

Police Recover £1M Stolen Jewellery in Hounslow, Owners Sought

The jewellery was largely taken from London’s South Asian community in Hounslow between 2023 and 2024. (Photo: Met Police)

Stolen jewellery worth £1m recovered in Hounslow, police seek owners

POLICE are seeking to reunite stolen jewellery worth over £1 million with its rightful owners after recovering the items during a proactive operation across London and the home counties.

The recovered collection includes identifiable pieces such as a World War One officer’s Rolex watch, a gold locket containing old pictures, an engraved gold ring, and an engraved gold pocket watch from Harlow Bros Ltd.

Keep ReadingShow less
british-muslims

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

iStock)

Government announces fund to combat anti-Muslim hate

THE UK government has announced a new fund to monitor anti-Muslim hate and support victims, with applications opening on 7 April.

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

Keep ReadingShow less
Probe launched over racist broadcast at Kent asylum centre

FILE PHOTO: Entrance of Manston short-term holding centre for migrants, near Ramsgate in southeast England. (Photo by BEN STANSALL/AFP via Getty Images)

Probe launched over racist broadcast at Kent asylum centre

AUTHORITIES have launched an investigation following reports that a racist message was broadcast over portable radios at an asylum processing centre in Kent.

The incident occurred at the Manston site, where small boat arrivals are processed by the Home Office and its contractor, Mitie, reported The Guardian.

Keep ReadingShow less
Protest against dog crackdown ahead of Modi's Sri Lanka visit

Sri Lankan animal rights activists take part in a demonstration in Colombo on April 3, 2025, to protest the round-up of stray dogs a day ahead of a visit by Narendra Modi. (Photo by ISHARA S. KODIKARA/AFP via Getty Images)

Protest against dog crackdown ahead of Modi's Sri Lanka visit

SRI LANKAN animal rights activists marched on Thursday (3) to protest the round-up of stray dogs a day ahead of a visit by Indian prime minister Narendra Modi.

Authorities in Colombo and the Buddhist pilgrim city of Anuradhapura have reportedly deployed dog catchers to impound hounds ahead of Modi's visit, which begins on Friday (4).

Keep ReadingShow less
modi-trump-getty

Donald Trump and Narendra Modi hold a joint press conference in the East Room at the White House on February 13, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Explained: Impact of US tariffs on Indian exports

The United States has announced a 27 per cent reciprocal tariff on Indian goods entering the American market.

Industry experts have said these duties will pose challenges for Indian exports, though India's position remains more favourable than some of its competitors.

Keep ReadingShow less