Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Amartya Sen reveals the 1943 Bengal famine still haunts him

Amartya Sen reveals the 1943 Bengal famine still haunts him

Food poverty, not a lack of food, led millions to starve to death, says academic

THE economist Amartya Sen has written at length about the great Bengal famine of 1943 when he was a boy of 10 studying at Rabindranath Tagore’s Santiniketan school.


He is now 87, but the horrors he witnessed – and recalls in his memoir, Home in the World – are seared into his memory.

“The continuous cries for help – from children and women and men – ring in my ears even today, seventy-seven years later,” he writes.

One of the big issues that has resurfaced is the question of Winston Churchill’s alleged involvement in aggravating the effects of the famine.

Sen holds Churchill’s government responsible for censoring news about the famine: “The Bengali daily newspapers were heavily censored during the famine period, but the cultural magazines, with a relatively small readership, were rather freely sold.”

LEAD Amartya Sen INSET GettyImages 1229682940 Nobel laureate Amartya Sen. (Photo by INDRANIL MUKHERJEE/AFP via Getty Images)

He adds: “The Bengali cultural magazines were convinced that the starvation occurring in Bengal could have been stopped by getting more food into the economy, and they blamed the British government for not dealing with the famine.

One of these magazines, Desh, ran a striking editorial in July 1943 which presented the analogy of Emperor Nero playing the violin while Rome burnt. The editorial was sarcastically headlined ‘The Glory of the Churchill Government’. It proclaimed in powerful Bengali why the famine could have been averted if prime minister Winston Churchill had allowed more food to be brought into Bengal. This diagnosis may have overlooked some of the features of the government’s inability to understand what had caused the famine, but the basic thrust of its criticism of government policy was not seriously mistaken.”

Sen remembers that as a schoolboy at Santiniketan, “I saw the first signs of famine in April 1943 – the so-called ‘great Bengal famine’ which would kill between two and three million people. Food prices had started rising quite sharply during 1942, the year before the famine.”

There was an incident at school when two bullies were cruelly teasing a man who had appeared “with evident mental derangement”. The bullies were driven off by a gang of boys. The victim was “barely coherent, but we gathered that he had not eaten anything for a month. One of our teachers joined us …and we gathered from him that prolonged starvation often does produce mental derangement.”

People who were starving in the villages headed towards Calcutta (now Kolkata), and by July 1943, “the trickle had grown into a torrent of miserable humanity…Most of them were on their way to Calcutta, nearly a hundred miles away, having heard rumours of arrangements there for the feeding of destitutes. These rumours were exaggerated.

The government was not, in fact, providing any relief.” Sen remembers: “My grandmother allowed me to give a cigarette tin full of rice to anyone who begged for food, but she explained, ‘even if it breaks your heart, you cannot give any more than one tincan of rice to anyone, since we have to help as many people as we can.’”

His aunt rescued one refugee, Joggeshwar, “who came as an almost fatally hungry boy of 14 from Dumka, about 40 miles from Santiniketan”.

Although the Sen family did not need any more servants, he was taken on, remained on the staff for 70 years and “became the chief employee at our home”.

Sen adds: “When the famine erupted with great ferocity between the spring and summer of 1943, I was about to have my 10th birthday and I felt every confused…A maternal uncle, Kankarmama, said, ‘I don’t rule out a big famine.’ I was not yet absolutely sure what a famine really was, but I was full of apprehension. I did not, of course, know any economics, but I was aware that if food prices kept rising without people’s incomes going up, many would end up starving – and dying.”

Sen made his name with an explanation on the causes of famine. It is significant there hasn’t been a famine in independent India. During the Bengal famine, rice prices rocketed by a factor of five, placing it beyond the reach of poor villagers.

Sen’s analysis is that “there is a huge difference between food availability (how much food there is in the market as a whole) and food entitlement (how much each family can buy in the market). Starvation is a characteristic of people not being able to buy enough food in the market. In the 1970s, when I studied famines across the world, it became clear how important it was to focus on food entitlement – not food availability.”

In Bengal, “the largest group of famine victims were the rural workers. The government was not particularly worried about them…the distress in rural areas was thus reinforced through government policy.”

LEAD Amartya Sen INSET 1 Home in the World by Amartya Sen book cover July 2021

Sen observes “the British in India went in a very different direction from the British in Britain. Indeed, just when serious undernourishment was being eradicated in Britain, India suffered a gigantic famine – the Bengal famine of 1943 – which killed nearly three million people. How could a country ruled by the foremost democracy in Europe allow such a famine to develop?”

What prevented any remedial action was an embargo on all news about the famine. “The famine occurred during the Second World War when the British were in retreat, chased by the advancing Japanese military forces. The British were very afraid of the demoralisation that could arise from the free flow of information about the retreat of their forces. So the Raj rulers decided to restrict the flow of information, censoring the Bengali newspapers and severely restricting their freedom to publish. However, it did not formally censor the best-known English paper, the British-owned Statesman. Instead, the government appealed to its sense of patriotism – requesting that it should not do anything that could be detrimental to the British war efforts.”

After wrestling with his conscience for months, Ian Stephens, the English editor of the Statesman, broke his self-imposed embargo and published news about the catastrophe that had hit Bengal.

“After the Statesman’s editorials, the gravity of the situation could not but be discussed in London, and it received wide attention in the British papers,” says Sen.

“Within a few days there was a resolution for government intervention to stop the famine and within a few weeks official famine relief was instituted for the first time in the 1943 famine. Because the famine had been going on for nine months, more than a million people had already died. Eventually public persuasion resulted in a major change in policy.”

Years later, Sen met Stephens at Cambridge where the latter had become a senior research fellow at King’s College after his retirement from India.

“I learnt…why the suppression of public discussion can be disastrous for a population, even helping to usher in a famine,” writes Sen. “It was only after Stephens blew the whistle that the Parliament in Westminster had to discuss the famine and the British press demanded that it be stopped immediately. It was only then that the Raj had to take action.”

More For You

uk-floods

Flood waters rise near to the top of a bridge in Breamore, southern England on January 28, 2025, after heavy rain brought flooding to parts of England. (Photo: Getty Images)

Heavy rain and flooding disrupt travel across UK

HEAVY and strong winds have caused flooding and travel disruption across the UK.

The Met Office issued an amber weather warning for parts of Wales, while flood alerts were in place across England and Scotland.
Rainfall reached up to 100mm, with winds exceeding 70 mph in parts of Wales.

Keep ReadingShow less
London’s St Patrick’s Day parade returns
Sadiq Khan (Photo by Kate Green/Getty Images)

London’s St Patrick’s Day parade returns

LONDON's St Patrick’s Day parade and Trafalgar Square celebrations will take place on 16 March, bringing together residents and visitors to celebrate Irish culture. The event will feature a parade through central London and an afternoon of entertainment at Trafalgar Square, a statement said.

Paralympic gold medal-winning cyclist Katie-George Dunlevy and Olympic gold medal-winning boxer Kellie Harrington will be this year’s Grand Marshals. They will lead a parade of more than 50,000 people, featuring floats, marching bands, and dance groups. The procession will start at Hyde Park Corner and move through Piccadilly and Trafalgar Square before concluding at Whitehall.

Keep ReadingShow less
Starmer urges Trump to back Ukraine ahead of third anniversary

Keir Starmer, speaks during an interview on January 16, 2025 in Kyiv, Ukraine. (Photo by Carl Court/Getty Images)

Starmer urges Trump to back Ukraine ahead of third anniversary

PRIME MINISTER Keir Starmer said Saturday (22) it was in the "interest" of US President Donald Trump to "stand by" Ukraine, in comments ahead of the third anniversary of Russia's invasion.

"It is in UK and US interests to stand by Ukraine with security guarantee," Starmer wrote in an op-ed for the weekly The Sun on Sunday, published on its website late Saturday.

Keep ReadingShow less
Salman-Rushdie

Salman Rushdie, 77, was stabbed multiple times in the head, neck, torso, and left hand. (Photo: Getty Images)

Man who attacked Salman Rushdie found guilty of attempted murder

HADI MATAR, the man who attacked author Salman Rushdie on stage at a New York arts event in 2022, has been found guilty of attempted murder.

A jury convicted Matar, 27, on Friday after a trial at Chautauqua County Court in Mayville. During the attack, Matar rushed onto the stage at the Chautauqua Institution as Rushdie was being introduced for a discussion on writer safety. Some videos of the attack were shown to jurors during seven days of testimony.

Keep ReadingShow less
Apple-London-Reuters

People walk past an Apple store in London on January 13, 2025. (Photo: Reuters)

Apple to end advanced data protection for UK users

APPLE announced on Friday that it will no longer offer its full end-to-end encryption feature, Advanced Data Protection (ADP), for users in the United Kingdom.

The company said new users in the UK will not have access to ADP, and existing users will have to disable the feature.

Keep ReadingShow less