Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

BBC impartiality and Israel-Hamas conflict

If the BBC gives in over Hamas, this and future British governments will have made a rod for themselves

BBC impartiality and Israel-Hamas conflict

THE government is pressuring the BBC to refer to Hamas as “terrorists” instead of “militants” or “fighters” in its news reports.

But ministers should reflect on the consequences of taking such a stance. The BBC is part of British soft power precisely because it is independent of government.


Take, for example, the occasion when the Indian government reacted badly to the BBC’s two-part documentary on Narendra Modi earlier this year. The UK government resorted to its usual get-out of-jail card – it pointed out that however much it might disagree with the film, it could not tell the BBC what to do because it was an independent organisation.

If the BBC gives in over Hamas, this and future British governments will have made a rod for themselves. It will be asked by foreign administrations to intervene over BBC reports that they might not like.

Addressing a Jewish community vigil opposite Downing Street last Monday (9), the immigration minister Robert Jenrick condemned Hamas to loud cheers: “Let us be clear what the world has witnessed. These weren’t, as some in the media say, militants or fighters. They were terrorists. They were murderers. They were barbarians, and the BBC or whoever else we see on the television should say it as it is.”

John Simpson, world affairs editor of BBC News, hit back: “British politicians know perfectly well why the BBC avoids the word ‘terrorist’, and over the years plenty of them have privately agreed with it. Calling someone a terrorist means you’re taking sides and ceasing to treat the situation with due impartiality.

“The BBC’s job is to place the facts before its audience and let them decide what they think, honestly and without ranting. That’s why, in Britain and throughout the world, nearly half a billion people watch, listen to and read us. There’s always someone who would like us to rant. Sorry, it’s not what we do.”

If the BBC was seen to be taking sides, it could not report from both sides of a dispute. I knew my language was monitored by the Iranian authorities during long years in Iran when I reported on the students who took hostages at the US embassy in Teheran, the thousands of executions carried out by the regime, the Iran-Iraq war and the violence in a country in the throes of revolution.

I was very young and inexperienced, but I had to learn how to write several stories a day in the Daily Telegraph without using inflammatory language that would get me thrown out – or worse. It was much the same reporting the Falklands War from Buenos Aires.

Argentina, or stories from other “enemy datelines”.

I think that is the point the BBC is trying to make over covering Hamas. In the long run, it is more advantageous for the government to maintain a distance between itself and the BBC.

One invaluable lesson I learned in Iran was about the radical Islamist theory of chaos. That fitted in with the laws of chaos and the Brownian motion I had learnt in physics and in thermodynamics at university – things proceed from a state of disorder to greater disorder. In other words, things generally get worse.

This, I think, is Hamas’s thinking, which must have known that the Israeli response to its killings of more than 1,000 of its citizens, would be overwhelming. It wants to suck Israel into a state of even greater chaos.

After the 2008 Mumbai massacre, Manmohan Singh, then India’s prime minister, did something very difficult after the killing of 175 innocent people – he showed restraint, avoided “hot pursuit”, and basically did nothing.

Last week, I expressed the hope that the politics of the Israel-Hamas conflict wouldn’t spill over into Britain. It already has.

We are all familiar with the complex background to the Israel-Palestine conflict. I was lucky enough to have grown up with Jewish pupils, who were among my closest friends at school. They belong to a community that has much in common with aspirational British Asians. People know what I mean without having to spell it out. It is best to live in harmony in this country.

More For You

Comment: Reform split exposes the dangers of unchecked populist rhetoric

Reform UK's new MPs Richard Tice, Nigel Farage, Lee Anderson and Rupert Lowe pose during a presentation of their programme in London on July 5, 2024

Getty Images

Comment: Reform split exposes the dangers of unchecked populist rhetoric

IT took Nigel Farage 30 years to get elected as an MP until the voters of Clacton sent him to the Commons on his eighth attempt last summer. Having broken through by getting five Reform MPs, Farage has taken every opportunity to stoke the media hype in which supporters fantasise and his critics fear a populist wave could sweep him all the way into Downing Street next time. But there has been something of a reality check this month – with the new party splitting as relationships broke down between the leader and Rupert Lowe, the former Southampton FC chairman elected in Great Yarmouth.

The Farage-Lowe battle has many dimensions. It can be seen as a personality clash of political egos – which escalated after US billionaire businessman, Elon Musk, decided he preferred Lowe to Farage. It is an argument about Farage’s control of Reform’s structures – and the slow progress in giving party members any role. The Reform leadership says it is about personal conduct – even reporting Lowe to the police for alleged threats to party chair Zia Yusuf – but acted against Lowe only when he criticised the leader.

Keep ReadingShow less
Essence of Ramadan

Ramadan is a time for self-reflection and to become better human beings

Essence of Ramadan

THE word Ramadan conjures images of fasting, shared meals, and a sense of community, but there is a deeper, more profound purpose beneath the surface of this holy month for Muslims.

Ramadan is not just about abstaining from food and drink; it is a transformative journey of self-discovery, offering a chance to shed old habits and cultivate inner peace. It is a month of selfreflection, a time to become better human beings and reconnect with our values.

Keep ReadingShow less
Asian health workers paid
heavy price during Covid

The National Covid Memorial Wall on the Covid-19 Day of Reflection, marking five years since the start of the pandemic in London last Sunday (9)

Asian health workers paid heavy price during Covid

BEREAVED families and friends came together last Sunday (9) to remember the loss of loved ones as the UK marked five years since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Public memory is remarkably short; there was a time when people were prevented from even saying goodbye to their relatives as they died in hospital. To prevent contamination, their bodies were slipped into body bags for funerals where almost no one could come.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sunak symbolised how high
ethnic minority talent can rise

Rishi Sunak and his wife Akshata Murty

Sunak symbolised how high ethnic minority talent can rise

“MY POLITICAL journey was so quick,” former prime minister Rishi Sunak told Nick Robinson during a two-hour BBC podcast on his lessons from Downing Street.

Sunak’s meteoric rise and demise makes him a former prime minister at 44. Was it too much, too young? Did he make a mistake in grabbing a couple of years as prime minister after the implosion of Liz Truss?

Keep ReadingShow less
Are Tamil cinema’s big stars failing the industry?
Indian 2

Are Tamil cinema’s big stars failing the industry?

BOLLYWOOD’S recent string of big box of fice disasters has been well-documented, but Tamil cinema is also experiencing a tough period.

The industry, known as Kollywood, had one of its worst years in 2024, with a jaw dropping amount of money being lost on big-budget blockbusters that were rejected by audiences. Although there were a few successes, like Amaran and Maharaja, 2024, just like previous years, was dominated by expensive flops headlined by big-name stars that didn’t live up to expectations.

Keep ReadingShow less