Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Comment: Can Starmer government find the antidote to populist politics?

Tackling the politics of populism in Britain is primarily about how to get immigration right

Comment: Can Starmer government find the antidote to populist politics?

Keir Starmer

Getty Images

Donald Trump’s second inauguration as America's President next week is the sequel that few of us here wanted to see. Trump was the democratic choice of 50% of America's voters again this time, baffling most people on this side of the Atlantic. We share a common language and many cultural influences, but Britain is not America when it comes to politics.

But how confident can we be that Britain will not become as deeply divided as Donald Trump's America? The frenzy with which Elon Musk made himself the main character, opening this year in British politics, showed how technology shrinks the ocean between us. Britain is far from immune from the populist, polarised politics that took Trump to victory. This is a less deeply divided society than America, but the next four years are likely to see that tested as never before.


The British public are mainly balancers when it comes to the key challenges presented by this new Trump era. But can the centre hold off the populist challenge in volatile times?

The public want Keir Starmer’s government to strike a balance in navigating choppy diplomatic waters. Only one in six people want the prime minister to focus more on the UK-US partnership, while a third would prioritise Britain’s European links. Giving American and European relationships equal priority is the most popular choice for the voters of every party, in new Focaldata research for British Future. The challenges of this new Trump era have helped to put Britain’s Brexit divides into perspective. Keir Starmer and his European counterparts have broad, pragmatic permission to forge closer relationships to advance mutual interests - on growth, security, climate and managing migration effectively.

The British are mostly balancers on the great free speech debate - seeing the risks of both over-policing and under-policing online speech. Robust arguments must be part of a democratic society, but platforms should not be lax on hatred, abuse and the incitement to violence.

Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg last week honoured Donald Trump’s US mandate by ditching fact-checking and weakening Facebook’s rules on extreme content. Zuckerberg was quite open about his plan being to press Trump’s White House to deter other governments from policies or regulations which might cut into platform profits. Elon Musk's mission to bring down the British government reflects a complex cocktail of impulse, insomnia and hard-headed business interests. Musk can gain by exporting instability and polarisation.

So expect Trump’s alliance with the tech billionaires to be a source of Transatlantic tension. Trump was never on the ballot here - and this American push to weaken enforcement against hateful conduct is likely to strengthen the social consensus here that the major platforms have got this balance wrong.

One reason America’s polarisation runs so deep is that it includes so many hot button issues. Some of America’s deepest divides - such as abortion and gun control - are on issues where there is a settled British consensus. The core principles of the NHS unite Britain as much as the politics of healthcare divide the US.

Populism in Britain has a much clearer focus - on immigration and asylum - spilling over into adjacent issues of race and integration.

Tackling the politics of populism in Britain is primarily about how to get immigration right. Most people are balancers on immigration too - seeing pressures and gains from immigration and wanting to see the government combine control and compassion on asylum. But the increasingly polarised politics of immigration make holding that centre-ground difficult.

Donald Trump Getty Images

At British Future we’re working with Frank Sharry, among the leading US experts on immigration politics, to understand the lessons from Trump’s victory and the Democrats’ defeat for those seeking to defuse populism in Britain.

Sharry was a lead adviser to the Kamala Harris campaign on immigration. But he was frustrated by how the Democrat strategy of talking about the economy instead -– hoping not to increase the profile of immigration – allowed Trump to define the agenda and Kamala Harris in his own terms.


One big lesson for Keir Starmer from the American experience is that, in government, you have to get the politics and the policy right”, he says. Opposition and populist parties can talk about the issue. Governments need to deliver solutions too. The Biden administration, having struggled with the border crisis for three years, made dramatic progress in his final year on unauthorised crossings, but too late to change the politics.

The stakes are high on whether Keir Starmer’s government can now find the antidote to the populist politics of immigration. Sharry adds: "Populists weaponise migration in order to exploit grievances and gain power. Centre-left Democrats – from the UK to the US to the EU – need to manage and mitigate migration with control and compassion to extend and defend democracy. We got it wrong in America. We are counting on Labour and the UK to get it right." Britain is not America. Learning from what went wrong can help us to keep it that way.


Sunder Katwala

Sunder Katwala is the director of the think tank British Future and a regular contributor to Eastern Eye

More For You

Sir Sajid Javid leads commission 'tackling social divisions'

Sir Sajid Javid (Photo by Tom Nicholson-WPA Pool/Getty Images)

Sir Sajid Javid leads commission 'tackling social divisions'

A cross-party group has been formed to tackle the deep divisions that sparked last summer's riots across England. The new commission will be led by former Tory minister Sir Sajid Javid and ex-Labour MP Jon Cruddas.

The Independent Commission on Community and Cohesion has backing from both prime minister Sir Keir Starmer and Tory leader Kemi Badenoch. It brings together 19 experts from different political parties and walks of life.

Keep ReadingShow less
​Masum

Masum was seen on CCTV trying to steer the pram away and, when she refused to go with him, stabbed her multiple times before walking away and boarding a bus. (Photo: West Yorkshire Police)

West Yorkshire Police

Habibur Masum convicted of murdering estranged wife in front of baby

A MAN who stabbed his estranged wife to death in Bradford in front of their baby has been convicted of murder.

Habibur Masum, 26, attacked 27-year-old Kulsuma Akter in broad daylight on April 6, 2024, stabbing her more than 25 times while she pushed their seven-month-old son in a pram. The baby was not harmed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trump-Getty

Trump said that while deals are being made with some countries, others may face tariffs.

Getty Images

Trump says major trade deal with India may be finalised soon

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump on Friday said a "very big" trade deal could be finalised with India, suggesting significant movement in the ongoing negotiations between the two countries.

“We are having some great deals. We have one coming up, maybe with India. Very big one. Where we're going to open up India," Trump said at the “Big Beautiful Bill” event at the White House.

Keep ReadingShow less
starmer-getty

A total of 126 Labour MPs had publicly supported a move to block the proposals, marking the biggest rebellion under Starmer’s leadership so far. (Photo: Getty Images)

getty images

Starmer government softens welfare cuts after Labour MPs revolt

THE GOVERNMENT has backtracked on plans to reduce disability and sickness benefits following a major rebellion by MPs from within the Labour Party.

Care minister Stephen Kinnock confirmed on Friday that concessions had been made to address concerns raised by lawmakers who opposed the proposed reforms. This comes just days after prime minister Keir Starmer had said he would continue with the changes.

Keep ReadingShow less
Axiom Mission 4

(From left) Axiom Mission 4 Mission Specialist Tibor Kapu, Pilot Shubhanshu Shukla, Commander Peggy Whitson, and Mission Specialist Sławosz Uznański-Wiśniewski wave from inside the Space Dragon spacecraft. (Photo: NASA)

NASA

India’s Shubhanshu Shukla and 3 others dock at ISS after 28-hour journey

INDIA’s Shubhanshu Shukla and three other astronauts entered the International Space Station (ISS) on Thursday after a 28-hour journey aboard the Dragon spacecraft. The crew received warm hugs and handshakes upon arrival as the capsule docked with the orbital laboratory.

The spacecraft, named Grace and fifth in the Dragon series, made a soft capture with the ISS’s Harmony module at 4:01 pm IST while flying over the North Atlantic Ocean. Full docking procedures, including power links and pressure checks, took about two more hours to complete.

Keep ReadingShow less