Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

'Forced adoption': what does the law say?

The UK parliament passed the Children Act 1989, which made the child’s welfare the paramount consideration.

'Forced adoption': what does the law say?

Thousands of parents in Britain have had their children removed and adopted without their consent since the turn of the century -- many more than in any of its European neighbours.

This is largely due to the UK legal system's focus on the well-being of the child, and the requirement only to convince a judge that a child may be at risk of future harm.


Here is the legal situation in England and Wales. Scotland, which has its separate legal system, is broadly similar.

Child's welfare 

Adoption was historically focused on meeting the needs of adults rather than children and it was not until 1976 that it became part of the wider child protection system, allowing courts to dispense with parental consent.

The UK parliament passed the Children Act 1989, which made the child's welfare the paramount consideration.

Judge Brenda Hale stated at the time that "there is no question of a parental right" while politician John Kerr explained it "is only as a contributor to the child's welfare that parenthood assumes any significance".

Threshold 

A child can only be removed from his or her family with the authorisation of the family court if it is satisfied that the child is "suffering, or is likely to suffer, significant harm" due to parental action.

Harm is defined as meaning "ill-treatment or the impairment of health or development, including, for example, impairment suffered from seeing or hearing the ill-treatment of another".

Hale stressed the state "does not and cannot take away the children of all the people who commit crimes, who abuse alcohol and drugs, who suffer from physical and mental illnesses or who espouse anti-social political or religious beliefs".

But campaigners complain that the rules are ultimately subjective and that the "crystal ball" method can lead to children being removed from mothers on the grounds that they have mental health issues or are victims of domestic abuse.

Adoption

A child may only be placed for adoption either with the parents' consent or where the court makes a "placement order", authorising the local authority to place a child for adoption.

If the parent has not consented to the placement, the court must be satisfied that parental consent should be dispensed with.

Once the child is the subject of a placement order, parental responsibility is given to the local authority.

After the placement order, the child will be placed with prospective adopters pending a final adoption order.

While it is possible to overturn an adoption order, in reality, it only occurs in highly exceptional circumstances.

Contact

When a child is in the care of the local authority, parents must be allowed reasonable contact with the child.

Once placed for adoption, any contact will be ended.

EU system 

The English adoption system has caused tension between the government and several European Union member states, in particular Latvia, Slovakia and Bulgaria.

Latvia's parliament formally complained to the House of Commons that children of Latvian descent were being adopted by British families, without parental consent.

In one case, the embassy of Bulgaria observed in a non-participatory capacity and suggested several options for the alternative care of a Bulgarian child, rather than her adoption in England.

And several hundred protesters gathered outside the British embassy in Bratislava in 2012 in protest over Slovak children adopted in Britain.

Every country in Europe has a mechanism for permitting adoption without parental consent, in certain circumstances, but "few –- if any –- States exercise this power to the extent to which the English courts do," according to an EU report on the issue.

(AFP)

More For You

Ambanis-Getty

Billionaire businessman Mukesh Ambani with his wife and founder chairperson of the Reliance Foundation Nita Ambani during the wedding reception ceremony of actor Amir Khan's daughter, Ira Khan on January 13, 2024. (Photo: Getty Images)

Ambanis set to acquire minority stake in Hundred’s Oval Invincibles

THE OWNERS of the Indian Premier League (IPL) team Mumbai Indians have reportedly secured a deal to acquire a 49 per cent stake in Oval Invincibles, a franchise in England’s Hundred competition.

Reports on Thursday stated that Reliance Industries Limited (RIL), which owns Mumbai Indians, emerged as the successful bidder.

Keep ReadingShow less
trump-white-house-getty

peaking at a press conference, Trump confirmed that all those aboard both aircraft had died and cited pilot error on the military helicopter as a factor in the crash. (Photo: Getty Images)

Trump blames diversity policies for Washington air collision

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump on Thursday blamed diversity hiring policies for a mid-air collision between an airliner and a military helicopter over Washington’s Potomac River, which left 67 people dead.

Speaking at a press conference, Trump confirmed that all those aboard both aircraft had died and cited pilot error on the military helicopter as a factor in the crash. However, he focused on diversity policies under former presidents Joe Biden and Barack Obama, claiming they prevented qualified employees from being hired at the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA).

Keep ReadingShow less
Crackdown on ‘fake news’ sparks dissent in Pakistan

A journalist holds a banner during a protest in Islamabad on Tuesday (28)

Crackdown on ‘fake news’ sparks dissent in Pakistan

PAKISTAN criminalised online disinformation on Tuesday (28), passing legislation dictating punishments of up to three years in jail and prompting journalist protests accusing the government of quashing dissent.

The law targets anyone who “intentionally disseminates” information online that they have “reason to believe to be false or fake and likely to cause or create a sense of fear, panic or disorder or unrest”.

Keep ReadingShow less
India shifts defence strategy while balancing western ties and Russian legacy

India produces some military hardware but still relies heavily on imports. The BrahMos missile system featured in India’s 76th Republic Day parade in New Delhi last Sunday (26)

India shifts defence strategy while balancing western ties and Russian legacy

INDIA’S efforts to pare back its reliance on Russian military hardware are bearing fruit after the courting of new Western allies and a rapidly growing domestic arms industry, analysts said.

At a time when Moscow’s military-industrial complex is occupied with the ongoing war in Ukraine, India has made the modernisation of its armed forces a top priority.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pushkar Singh Dhami

Uttarakhand chief minister Pushkar Singh Dhami said the law promotes 'equality.' (Photo: X/@pushkardhami)

India's Uttarakhand implements common civil code

THE INDIAN state of Uttarakhand has begun implementing a common civil code to replace religious laws, a move that has raised concerns among minority Muslims about a possible nationwide rollout by the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

Indian prime minister Narendra Modi’s BJP has long advocated for a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) to standardise laws on marriage, divorce, and inheritance across India. On Monday, Uttarakhand became the second Indian state to enact such a law.

Keep ReadingShow less