Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Heart surgeon 'turned down' training on pioneering robot he used in operation where patient died

heart surgeon reportedly turned down the chance to train on a robot he used in an operation in which the patient later died.

Stephen Pettitt, 69, suffered multiple organ failure and died days after the procedure at the Freeman Hospital in Newcastle in March 2015.


Pettitt's heart valve operation was assisted by a robot and it was the first of its type at the trust.

On 4 November a coroner was told that the lead surgeon, Sukumaran Nair, reportedly admitted to a colleague that he could undergo more training on the sophisticated system. The robotics experts who were assisting the surgical team left part-way through the operation without informing staff.

Although robots such as the Da Vinci system are used to enable accurate key-hole surgery, the surgery in 2015, which was done to repair a mitral valve, damaged the interatrial septum, forcing the team to open Pettitt’s chest to repair the tear, reports indicate.

"By that time the operation had been going on for a considerable period of time," pathologist Nigel Cooper was quoted as saying by the Telegraph. “By the end of the surgery, the heart was functioning very poorly."

Although attempts were made to improve the heart function, Pettitt's organs began to shut down and he could not recover.

After the patient died, Nair telephoned Paul Renforth, a co-ordinator in the use of robotics at the Freeman Hospital, to say "the procedure had not gone as planned."

Renforth added: "(He said) possibly he could have done some more dry-run training."

The co-ordinator also said that the atmosphere in the operating room was tense.

The five-day inquest, which was attended by Pettitt’s sister and daughter, continues

More For You

Racist incidents against NHS nurses rise 78 per cent

The RCN says calls from ethnic minority nurses reporting racism rose by 70 per cent between 2022 and 2025

iStock

Racist incidents against NHS nurses rise 78 per cent

Highlights

  • Nursing staff reported 6,812 racist incidents in 2025, up from 3,652 in 2022.
  • RCN warns real figures are far higher due to widespread under-reporting.
  • From October, NHS employers will be legally liable for harassment of staff by patients.
Racist abuse against NHS nurses has gone up sharply. New figures show a 78 per cent rise in reported incidents over the past four years.
The Royal College of Nursing gathered this data through Freedom of Information requests sent to NHS trusts and health boards across the UK.
The findings show that nursing staff reported more than 21,000 incidents of racial abuse between 2022 and 2025. In 2025 alone, there were 6,812 incidents, up from 3,652 in 2022.
That means a new report of racist abuse was being made every 77 minutes somewhere in the NHS.

The incidents paint a disturbing picture of what many nurses face on a daily basis. One nurse was called a monkey by a colleague.

A patient threw a hot drink at a nurse and then followed it with racial abuse. In one case, a patient's family said they did not want black nurses looking after their relative.

Keep ReadingShow less