Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Immigration policy: How open will Britain be?

by LAUREN CODLING

THE ruling Conservative and opposition Labour parties both outlined their respective plans for immigration during election campaigns this week, without committing to numbers or confirming if migration will increase or decrease after Britain leaves the EU.


Policies regarding immigration and a control over numbers entering the UK have become central to parties’ election campaigns.

Setting out its post-Brexit immigration policy, the Tory party said last Sunday (17) it would treat migrants from EU and non-EU countries on par from January 2021, including a five-year wait to obtain welfare payments and a surcharge to access health services.

“As we come out of the EU, we have a new opportunity for fairness and to make sure all those who come here are treated the same. We will make our immigration system equal,” prime minister Boris Johnson said in a statement.

In previous years the Conservatives pledged to reduce migration to tens of thousands, from the prevailing hundreds of thousands. However, successive governments led by David Cameron and Theresa May have failed to honour that pledge. Senior ministers have made clear they would be giving up the party’s commitment to reduce net migration down below 100,000 a year.

Under Johnson, the Conservatives have proposed introducing an Australian-style, points-based system for nationals of all countries, including India, in the hope that it will “reduce immigration overall”.

Home secretary Priti Patel said immigration would “finally be subject to democratic control, allowing us to get overall numbers down”. “We will reduce immigration overall while being more open and flexible to the highly skilled people we need, such as scientists and doctors. This can only happen if people vote for a Conservative majority government so we can leave the EU with a deal,” Patel said.

Last weekend, Labour said that it would allow “a great deal of movement” of people, signalling a liberal immigration policy overall.

However, speaking ahead of the manifesto launch on Thursday (21), party leader Jeremy Corbyn stopped short of confirming that freedom of movement would not end after the UK left the EU. He later stressed a Labour government led by him would not bring in a “hostile environment”, a policy associated with May, during her term as home secretary.

Liberal Democrats leader Jo Swinson – who is running on a pledge to revoke Brexit – has called immigration “a good thing” and argued the UK benefits from it.

Criticising plans proposed by the Conservatives, Swinson said they were “predicated on an assumption that people coming to our country are trying to ‘do us over’.

“At the moment we cause fear in those communities for the hoops we make them jump through for settled status – we are better than this,” she told reporters.

Immigration was one of the key factors of the 2016 referendum, which resulted in the UK voting to leave the EU.

Speaking to Eastern Eye, Jonathan Portes, professor of economics and public policy at King’s College, London, noted that the main parties appeared to adopt a “less restrictive approach” to immigration than under former prime minister May.

“Whatever happens, there may be some improvement, although policy towards EU migrants will depend on Brexit,” Portes explained.

In 2012, then-home secretary May implemented the controversial hostile environment policies which were designed to make staying in the UK as difficult as possible for people without leave to remain status.

Sunder Katwala, director of the nonpartisan thinktank British Future, claimed parliament would see the “biggest immigration reform for a generation”, if Johnson secured the majority.

“If a hung parliament means new negotiations or another referendum, then Labour and the Liberal Democrats would need to win the argument for free movement,” Katwala told Eastern Eye. Analysing the proposals so far, Katwala said the party-political debate had “moved closer to where the public are”.

“(They are) seeing both pressures and gains of immigration, in its contribution to the NHS, universities and skills we need,” the thinktank leader said.

Speaking to Eastern Eye, public affairs and campaigns manager at Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI) Minnie Rahman called the snap election a “golden opportunity” to rebuild the immigration system. Referring to current policies as “racist, unfair and unfit for purpose,” Rahman recommended the elected government dismantle the hostile environment.

She also urged to maintain freedom of movement for EU citizens, remove the minimum income requirement for spouse visas, and reform the asylum system so “people can have their claims heard fairly and without delay.”

Fizza Qureshi, the co-CEO of Migrants’ Rights Network, said the organisation was disappointed by some proposals from leading parties which suggested they would be ending free movement. It will leave many people living in the UK and overseas in uncertainty, Qureshi told Eastern Eye, and felt like a shortsighted move when the country is so

heavily reliant on migrants for a successful economy.

“We would welcome all the parties to consider the impact their proposed policies have when they talk about numbers of people, targets and skills on migrants and settled BAME communities, and wider society,” Qureshi said.

“If we can’t make the UK a welcoming place then no-one will be attracted to come and make the UK their home."

Reflecting upon the current policies and outlines for the future, Matthew Fell, Confederation of British Industry’s (CBI) chief UK policy director, urged for a system which would work for the UK economy.

“(It) is as important as forging a new economic relationship with the EU, our biggest trading partner,” Fell said. “Businesses know change is coming and will need time to adapt. But there is concern that the focus of a new system is so squarely on skills – the UK has labour shortages that must also be filled.”

Business and government need to work together to train UK workers, he said, while developing an open but controlled immigration system that grows our economy.

Responding to immigration policies put forward by the Conservatives, Labour’s shadow home secretary Diane Abbott said the damage done to society had been through cuts by the

governing party to public services and “not by EU nationals coming to work in them.”

As Eastern Eye went to press on Tuesday (19), Johnson and Corbyn were due to go head-to-head in their first TV debate of the election campaign, facing scrutiny over their plans for Brexit and public spending.

Prior to the debate, polls showed the Conservatives had surged ahead with an 11-point lead. They had an average of 39.9 per cent, ahead of Labour on 29.0 per cent. Manifestos from each party are due to be released in the run-up to the December 12 election.

(With agencies)

More For You

Voices of Faith - Day 2: A profound confluence of spirituality, music, and dialogue

Barnaby Rogerson in conversation with Anthony Sattin (L) on day 2 of Voices of Faith

Voices of Faith - Day 2: A profound confluence of spirituality, music, and dialogue

Mahesh Liloriya

The second day of Voices of Faith unfolded with an enchanting blend of music, philosophy, and intellectual exploration at the Barbican Centre, London. This inaugural festival, curated by Teamwork Arts—the force behind the Jaipur Literature Festival (JLF) and JLF London—has been made possible by the Kamini and Vindi Banga Family Trust, with the support of Tech Mahindra. Eastern Eye and Garavi Gujarat serve as the official media partners, amplifying the festival’s reach and resonance.

Session 1- Echoes of eternity: The timeless notes of Kabir

Keep ReadingShow less
starmer-immigration

Speaking at the Organised Immigration Crime Summit, Starmer said the government is working to restore order to the immigration system.

UK returns 24,000 illegal migrants since July, highest in eight years

THE UK government has returned over 24,000 individuals with no legal right to remain in the country since July, marking the highest rate of removals in eight years, prime minister Keir Starmer said on Monday.

Speaking at the Organised Immigration Crime Summit, Starmer said the government is working to restore order to the immigration system.

Keep ReadingShow less
'Aga Khan dedicated his life to service, peace, and pluralism'

Baroness Patricia Scotland speaks at an Iftar dinner held at the Ismaili Centre in London (Photo: The Ismaili National Council for the United Kingdom)

'Aga Khan dedicated his life to service, peace, and pluralism'

THE outgoing head of the Commonwealth has paid tribute to the late Prince Karim Aga Khan, describing him as a visionary leader whose lifelong dedication to service, peace, and pluralism has left a lasting impact on the world.

Speaking at an Iftar dinner held at the Ismaili Centre in London last Wednesday (26), Baroness Patricia Scotland, who steps down as Commonwealth secretary general on 1 April, reflected on her personal connection with the Aga Khan, recalling their meetings during Commonwealth Day celebrations at Westminster Abbey.

Keep ReadingShow less
Starmer-Trump-Getty

Trump has suggested the possibility of a 'great' trade deal that could help the UK mitigate the impact of tariffs he has pledged to introduce. (Photo: Getty Images)

Starmer, Trump talk trade deal progress in 'productive' discussion

KEIR STARMER and Donald Trump spoke on Sunday about ongoing UK-US trade negotiations, with Downing Street describing the talks as "productive."

Since leaving the European Union, the UK has been working to secure a trade agreement with the United States. Successive British governments have pursued a deal, but it has remained elusive.

Keep ReadingShow less
Myanmar-quake-rescue-Reuters

Rescuers carry the body of a victim during search and rescue operations, following a strong earthquake, in Bangkok, Thailand, March 30. (Photo: Reuters)

Myanmar earthquake death toll rises to 1,700, UK pledges £10m in aid

RESCUE efforts continued in Myanmar as residents searched for survivors in collapsed buildings in Mandalay, two days after a 7.7-magnitude earthquake struck the country. The disaster has killed at least 1,700 people in Myanmar and 17 in neighbouring Thailand.

The quake hit near Mandalay on Friday afternoon, followed minutes later by a 6.7-magnitude aftershock. The tremors caused widespread destruction, damaging buildings, bridges, and roads in the city of more than 1.7 million people.

Keep ReadingShow less