Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Kolkata’s sex workers face hypocrisy as brothel soil becomes sacred for Durga Puja

Amid Hindu rituals, society reveres the earth outside brothels but ignores the women who live within

Kolkata’s sex workers face hypocrisy as brothel soil becomes sacred for Durga Puja
An artisan works on a clay idol of goddess Durga at Kumartoli in Kolkata

EVERY year in India’s megacity Kolkata, the world’s oldest trade gets fleeting respect from an ancient custom – when soil outside brothels is considered sacred and collected for Hindu rituals.

Those working in the eastern port city’s ever-busy red light district say the coveted earth is a bitter reflection of society’s discriminatory attitudes – desired when needed, downtrodden filth when not.


The doorstep dirt is seen as holy by Hindu devotees, who believe it is imbued with special qualities because it is where men leave behind all that is good before entering for sex.

This scooped-up soil is included in clay to make brightly-coloured idols of the beloved goddess Durga, or used to give an earth “bath” of the statues made for the festival.

Sex worker Salima, a lady in her thirties working in Kolkata’s Sonagachi red light district, is angered at the dirt-gathering tradition. In the eyes of society, she is seen as having “no dignity”, said Salima, not her real name.

Gathering the soil is part of the celebrations for Durga Puja, the biggest festival in the eastern state of West Bengal, with celebrations this year beginning in October. “When you want the soil from my hand, you suddenly respect me,” she said.

“What kind of a rule is this?” A spokeswoman for sex worker association Durbar Mahila Samanwaya Committee said its members tried to stop artisans from taking the soil.

The week-long festival celebrates the victory of Durga – a powerful multiarmed goddess often depicted riding a lion, revered as a protective mother – over a demon.

“The men who enter the sex worker’s house leave all the good in them at her doorstep,” said Jayanta Kushary, 64, who is the founder of the Sarva Bharatiya Prachya Vidya Academy, which teaches Indian culture.

“That is why that soil from outside the sex worker’s house is considered holy.”

Kushary said the soil should be used to “wash” idols.

However, families in Kolkata also use the soil to make idols themselves, which are then venerated before being immersed into the holy River Ganges at the festival’s culmination.

Samar Dutt’s family has used the soil both for idols and holy baths for more than a century – and he for one decries how sex workers are often shunned and looked down on.

“They are not the dark side of society,” he said. “They are equal with other people.”

Dutt said modern construction with concrete and tarmac roads meant that sometimes finding a good place to collect the soil was hard.

So artists have found a solution.

“The sex worker goes to take a bath in the Ganges, and gets soil from there,” he said. “Then she keeps it outside her house, from where it is collected.”

Kushary insisted that it was important for the society to respect sex workers.

“They are very, very important to our society,” he said. “The sex worker is a social worker.”

The Hindu festival is a busy time in the red light zone.

Soliciting for sex is illegal, but workers say police often turn a blind eye in exchange for cash.

But the sex workers say none of the men collecting dirt have invited them to join a Durga Puja celebration.

“They don’t even recognise us,” said Pushpa, whose name has been changed to protect her identity, adding the men “look at us with disgust”.

“The women think we will snatch their husbands if we talk to them,” she said. “But we have no such thoughts.”

Salima said her family has little idea how she earns her living, work she turned to because she had no alternative. “We don’t like doing this work,” Salima said.

“When the men come, they ask us to do many things. They say they won’t use a condom, that they don’t like it. Helpless, we say ‘okay’, but we don’t feel right”.

More For You

Southport stabbings: Teenager  denies charges in court

Southport murder suspect Axel Rudakubana appears via video link at the Westminster Magistrates' Court in London, Britain, October 30, 2024, in this courtroom sketch.

Julia Quenzler/Handout via REUTERS.

Southport stabbings: Teenager  denies charges in court

A British teenager had not guilty pleas entered on his behalf to charges of murdering three young girls in a knife attack in northern England in July, a crime that horrified the nation and was followed by days of nationwide rioting.

Axel Rudakubana, 18, on Wednesday (18) did not speak when asked at Liverpool Crown Court if he was guilty or not guilty of killing Bebe King, 6, Elsie Dot Stancombe, 7, and Alice Dasilva Aguiar, 9, who were at a Taylor Swift-themed dance event in the town of Southport.

Keep ReadingShow less
Gisele-Pelicot-Getty

This court-sketch made on December 19 shows Gisele Pelicot during the hearing of the verdict of the court that sentenced her ex-husband to the maximum term of 20 years jail. (Photo: Getty Images)

Dominique Pelicot sentenced to 20 years for organising mass rapes of ex-wife

A FRENCH court sentenced Dominique Pelicot to 20 years in prison on Thursday for orchestrating and committing the mass rapes of his former wife, Gisele Pelicot.

Pelicot, who had admitted to drugging his wife over nearly a decade to enable assaults by strangers he recruited online, was convicted by the criminal court in Avignon after a trial lasting more than three months.

Keep ReadingShow less
water-supply-iStock

Southern Water, which requested the highest rise at 83 per cent, will increase bills by 53 per cent. (Representational image: iStock)

Water bills to rise by 36 per cent to address infrastructure issues

WATER regulator Ofwat has announced that household water bills will increase by an average of 36 per cent over the next five years to fund major improvements in the country’s water infrastructure.

This move aims to address long-standing issues in the privatised water sector, including sewage spills and ageing systems.

Keep ReadingShow less
Mumbai-boat-capsize-Reuters

A military helicopter flies over a ferry during a rescue operation after a passenger boat capsized off the coast of Mumbai. (Photo: Reuters)

13 dead as Indian Navy speedboat collides with ferry near Mumbai

THIRTEEN people have died after an Indian Navy speedboat collided with a ferry near Mumbai during engine trials, authorities said on Wednesday.

Maharashtra state chief minister Devendra Fadnavis confirmed the fatalities and said over 100 people had been rescued.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bank of England
The Bank of England building is seen surrounded by flowers in London. (Photo: Reuters)

Bank of England likely to hold interest rates at 4.75 per cent

THE BANK OF ENGLAND is expected to maintain its interest rate at 4.75 per cent on Thursday, even as the economy shows signs of slowing. Persistent inflation pressures are likely to prompt the central bank to stick to a "gradual" approach before reducing borrowing costs.

A Reuters poll of 71 economists unanimously predicted no change in rates for now. Most anticipate a quarter-point cut on 6 February, followed by three additional cuts by the end of 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less