AT 16, Payzee Mahmod was coerced by her Iraqi-Kurdish family in London into marrying a man around twice her age.
Two years later her elder sister Banaz, who had left a marriage she was forced into aged 17, was murdered by members of her family in a so-called honour killing.
Laws in England and Wales, which allow 16- and 17-year-olds to get married as long as they have parental consent, offered the teenage girls little redress at the time.
But nearly two decades on, a renewed legislative bid to change the minimum age for marriage to 18, and criminalise those organising underage unions, looks set to succeed.
"I'm absolutely ecstatic that this is happening - it's about time," Mahmod said outside the UK’s parliament in London, where the bill is poised to pass in the coming weeks.
"This is something that could have really protected me and my sister and all the children that have been going through this harmful practice."
'Global issue'
Campaigners hope it could help spur changes in other countries where under-18s are still allowed to marry - from Scotland, which has a separate legal system to England and Wales, to the majority of US states.
"This is a global issue," said Mahmod, who has been publicly advocating for reform for several years.
Britain has committed to the United Nations' sustainable development goals, which include outlawing child marriage by 2030.
"I'm hoping it will have a bit of a domino effect," said Conservative lawmaker Pauline Latham, who is behind the bill.
Latham launched the proposal after learning the UK was asking countries receiving aid to stop child marriage, even though it had not done so itself.
"It had never really occurred to me before that we did have child marriage," she said. "But we do... and once this bill goes through it'll stop."
The UK outlawed forced marriage in 2014 but that is seen as insufficient to protect teenagers because it requires victims to testify against the perpetrators - who are typically their parents.
The number of coerced 16- and 17-year-olds is hard to ascertain because whether they had agreed can be hard to determine. Some unions are often not registered legally.
In 2018, officials recorded 147 legal marriages of under-18s in England and Wales - involving 28 boys and 119 girls - while there were 183 the prior year.
"But it's the ones that are never registered that we don't know about," Latham said, adding her bill would also prevent minors from being taken abroad for marriage.
"It's fantastic legislation and it will transform the life chances of so many young people because they'll be able to finish their education."
It is currently progressing through parliament unopposed.
The government has cautioned that once it becomes law, enforcement may not start before the summer school holidays when underage marriages abroad often spike.
Banaz Mahmod's 2006 murder drew international attention and saw her father, uncle and a third killer receive lengthy jail sentences.
But it prompted no change to the law.
Now 34, Payzee Mahmod said she still struggles with the legacy of her own forced union, which lasted less than two years after she filed for divorce on turning 18.
"I experienced financial abuse, I experienced mental and physical abuse, and this is the reality of child marriage," she said.
Mahmod said opportunities for support were missed by those in positions to help, from healthcare workers to staff at the college she attended.
"I wasn't only let down by the people around me, but I was also let down by every professional that I came into contact with.
"Nobody ever gave me any support or saw that this was wrong and that I was a child and I should've been protected."
Little opposition
Sara Browne, of women's rights organisation IKWRO, said criminalising the organising of child marriages and increasing oversight are also key.
"We need safeguarding professionals - teachers, the police, healthcare workers - to know that if a child marriage is happening that is wrong, and that that child needs... protecting," she said.
"(It) can happen at a very young age... preparations for child marriage can happen at birth."
The campaigners said they had encountered little opposition to the change.
"One or two people said to me: 'What happens if the girl gets pregnant, and they're in love?'" Latham recalled.
"It's not about that. I'm not trying to stop love. I'm trying to stop children being allowed to marry."
(AFP)
Site Navigation
Search
AI Powered
Human content,
AI powered search.
Latest Stories
Start your day right!
Get latest updates and insights delivered to your inbox.
Related News
More For You
Carer's allowance penalties trap many in debt: report
Dec 12, 2024
HUNDREDS of thousands of unpaid carers have been hammered by harsh penalties for minor rule breaches, a damning national audit has revealed.
The National Audit Office (NAO) report exposed a system that has pushed vulnerable carers into financial and emotional turmoil.
According to the report, over 262,000 overpayments totalling £325 million were clawed back, with 600 carers even facing criminal prosecution.
The most shocking detail is the brutal "cliff-edge" earnings rule: earning just £1 over the £151 weekly threshold can trigger a repayment of £4,258.80 instead of just £52. Currently, 134,500 carers are struggling to repay over £251 million in debt.
Critically, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) appears to have deliberately understaffed its carer's allowance unit. Only half of electronic alerts identifying potential overpayments were investigated, with staff numbers cut by 14 per cent in two years.
Vivienne Groom, a former carer who was prosecuted and had a £16,000 inheritance seized, condemned the system. "They need to stop," she said. "I feel sorry for people who might lose their house or car."
Helen Walker from Carers UK described it as a "serious failure" causing immense distress, while Dominic Carter from Carers Trust called the system "broken".
Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey called it "a scandal of the DWP's own making" that has caused "misery and distress on a staggering scale".
The average family carer – often already in poverty – repays nearly £1,000 in overpayments annually. Some cases have accrued over £20,000 in undetected breaches.
The DWP, however, maintains that legally, claimants must inform them of eligibility changes. However, ministers have now launched an independent review due next summer to investigate why overpayments spiralled and how to protect carers.
Social security minister Stephen Timms acknowledged the challenges, promising to boost the earnings threshold to help over 60,000 people and "make the system fairer".
Keep ReadingShow less
Most Popular
Urfan Sharif had signed agreements prohibiting 'any physical chastisement' of children after facing multiple accusations of abuse.(Photo: Reuters)
Urfan Sharif was accused of abuse before Sara's birth: Report
Dec 12, 2024
SARA SHARIF’s father, Urfan Sharif, was repeatedly accused of abuse in the 13 years leading up to her murder, according to family court documents.
These records, according to The Times, reveal a history of physical abuse, neglect, and domestic violence within the family, with multiple interventions by social services.
Sara was made the subject of a child protection plan immediately after her birth in January 2013 due to concerns about harm from Sharif and her mother, Olga Domin.
The parents signed an agreement with social workers in September 2013, committing to attend a parenting course and to refrain from physical punishment, the newspaper reported.
Despite this, reports emerged that Sara exhibited signs of distress, including standing facing a wall and showing signs of developmental delay.
The family had been under the radar of social services since 2010. Allegations included domestic violence, physical abuse, and neglect. Police reports and school notifications highlighted incidents where children were found unsupervised, showed signs of assault, or displayed fear of returning home.
In 2014, one child suffered an adult bite mark, and Domin admitted to causing the injury in anger, later accepting a police caution, The Times reported. Social workers repeatedly noted ongoing domestic abuse and concerns over unexplained injuries among the children.
Despite intervention, Sara remained in her parents’ care. Reports from foster carers and schools pointed to further abuse, with children expressing fear of being hit. In one instance, Sara reported being slapped and pinched by her mother. In another, she claimed her mother attempted to drown her, the newspaper reported.
In 2019, Sharif secured custody of the children after alleging they were unsafe with Domin. Batool, Sharif’s partner, supported his custody application, claiming the children expressed disdain for their mother.
Sara’s body, bearing multiple injuries, was discovered in the family’s Surrey home in August last year.
Sharif and Batool fled to Pakistan but were later convicted of her murder.
Keep ReadingShow less
Teachers, nurses warn of strikes over 2.8 per cent pay rise proposal
Dec 11, 2024
TEACHERS and nurses may strike after the government recommended a 2.8 per cent pay rise for public sector workers for the next financial year.
Ministers cautioned that higher pay awards would require cuts in Whitehall budgets.
The British Medical Association (BMA) criticised the proposal, with its chair, Philip Banfield, stating that it demonstrates a "poor grasp" of unresolved issues, The Times reported.
"For this government to believe a 2.8 per cent pay rise is enough indicates a poor grasp of the unresolved issues from two years of industrial action," Banfield said.
Unison, representing nearly half a million NHS workers, and the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) also condemned the recommendation. Nicola Ranger, general secretary of the RCN, called the proposal "deeply offensive," adding, "The government has today told nursing staff they are worth as little as £2 extra a day."
The dispute follows earlier industrial actions across the public sector. Nurses and NHS staff are seeking an above-inflation increase, frustrated by this year’s 5.5 per cent rise, which was lower than the junior doctors’ 22 per cent deal over two years.
Helga Pile of Unison warned that the proposed rise "barely covers the cost of living." She added, "The decision to push tackling the outdated pay structure back into next year means there could well be more [strikes]," the newspaper reported.
Ministers argue the 2.8 per cent offer aligns with the Bank of England’s inflation forecast of 2.75 per cent, making it a real-terms increase. However, unions contend that pay adjustments fail to address ongoing workforce issues.
Education unions also voiced concerns. Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union, said, "There are no ‘efficiencies’ that can be made without further damaging education." He warned of potential action, emphasizing the "depth of the crisis" in schools.
A government spokesperson highlighted prior pay awards for over 1.5 million NHS staff and the resolution of recent strikes by junior doctors, adding, "We started the pay-setting process in September — the earliest it’s started for several years," The Times reported.
Keep ReadingShow less
Northern Ireland approves extension of post-Brexit trade rules
Dec 11, 2024
NORTHERN Ireland’s devolved government has voted to continue implementing post-Brexit trading arrangements under the Windsor Framework, a deal signed between London and the European Union in February 2023.
The vote in the Northern Ireland Assembly at Stormont extended the arrangement for four years.
A majority of lawmakers supported the motion, which did not require cross-community support from both pro-UK and pro-Irish unity members. However, the decision drew opposition from unionist members who argued that trade barriers between Great Britain and Northern Ireland still persist.
The vote triggered a response from the UK government, with Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn pledging an independent review of the trading arrangements. "The Government welcomes that [Assembly members] have agreed on the continued application of the Windsor Framework," Benn said in a statement. "I will now proceed as required by the law, including to commission an independent review."
Benn emphasised the government’s commitment to implementing the framework in good faith. "The government remains committed to implementing the Windsor Framework in a way that offers stability and works for Northern Ireland, for businesses, and for traders," he added.
The Windsor Framework keeps Northern Ireland within the EU’s single market for goods while removing checks on goods transported from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. This adjustment eliminated the Irish Sea border, which had been a point of contention for pro-UK unionists who feared it weakened ties between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK.
A central aspect of the 1998 Good Friday Agreement, which ended decades of sectarian violence, was maintaining an open border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. However, the UK’s 2016 Brexit vote introduced challenges, as Northern Ireland's open border could potentially allow unchecked goods to move in and out of the EU.
The 2020 post-Brexit trading arrangements sought to address this by introducing checks on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland while keeping the region partially aligned with EU rules.
(With inputs from AFP)
Keep ReadingShow less
'Covid bereavement rates in Scotland highest among Asians'
Dec 10, 2024
THE bereavement rates due to Covid in Scotland have been highest among those identifying with ‘Any other’ ethnic group (68 per cent), followed by Indians (44 per cent) and Pakistanis (38 per cent), a new study revealed. This is significantly higher than the national average of around 25 per cent.
Ethnic groups were found to be two-and-a-half times more likely to have experienced the loss of a close family member during the Covid crisis.
The report titled "Racism, Belonging and Covid's Legacy of Ethnic Inequalities in Scotland," published on Tuesday (10), noted that the impact of Covid has exacerbated these disparities, deepening ethnic inequalities across the region.
Jewish, Chinese, and Bangladeshi communities in Scotland reported lower levels of bereavement compared to their counterparts in England and Wales, the report added.
Several factors contribute to these disparities, including the differential impact of Covid-19, variations in family structures and social networks, underlying health differences, varying levels of poverty and deprivation, and access to care and support services, the report by researchers from the University of St Andrews noted.
The findings assume significance as Scotland's population is becoming increasingly diverse, with 13 per cent identifying as an ethnic minority other than white Scottish or white British.
The report from the Evidence for Equality National Survey (EVENS) highlighted the challenges and experiences of these ethnic minorities in Scotland, focusing on areas like Covid bereavement, racism, ethnic and national belonging, and political trust.
According to the report, one in four ethnic minorities reported facing recent racist insults, and 1 in 6 experienced unfair treatment at work or in education, with 1 in 10 encountering similar issues in housing or from the police. There have been physical attacks linked to racism, affecting 10 per cent of ethnic minorities.
"Black and Chinese communities report particularly high levels of racist insults and unfair treatment by the police. The experience of racism is generally comparable across ethnic groups in Scotland and England and Wales, with some evidence suggesting higher levels for Chinese, black Caribbean, and black Other groups in Scotland," the report, authored by Prof Nissa Finney from the School of Geography and Sustainable Development, said.
Over a third of ethnic minorities worry about racial harassment, with the concern particularly pronounced among Black, Pakistani, Indian, and Jewish communities.
Trust in the Scottish parliament remains high across ethnic groups, significantly more so than trust in the UK parliament.
Over the past five years, about a quarter of ethnic minorities in Scotland experienced racist insults or other forms of racism in public spaces. Overall, 38 per cent of ethnic minorities in Scotland are concerned about racial harassment.
This report, which addresses these issues, is a collaboration between researchers from the Centre on the Dynamics of Ethnicity (CoDE) at the University of St Andrews, the University of Manchester, and the Ethnic Minority Voluntary Sector umbrella body BEMIS.
The highest levels of concern are reported by Other black (78 per cent), Pakistani (66 per cent), Other Asian (61 per cent), white and black African (58 per cent), Indian (55 per cent), black Caribbean (52 per cent), and black African (50 per cent) ethnic groups, as well as Jewish groups (48 per cent). In Scotland, levels of worry about racial harassment are generally higher compared to those in England and Wales for many of these groups.
Religion plays a significant role in identity, with high proportions expressing its importance. For instance, black Caribbean and Mixed white and black Caribbean groups show 99 per cent importance, followed by White Irish (97 per cent) and Pakistani (95 per cent) groups.
Over three-quarters of black African, Arab, and Bangladeshi respondents see religion as crucial to their sense of self, and over two-thirds of Jewish and Chinese respondents share this view.
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More
© Copyright 2024 Garavi Gujarat Publications Ltd & Garavi Gujarat Publications