Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

‘Leadbeater, not Labour, won Batley and Spen’

‘Leadbeater, not Labour, won Batley and Spen’

“BATLEY and Spen” were the words on the rosette of a pumped-up Labour leader, Sir Keir Starmer, and “Battered and Spent” on a frazzled prime minister Boris Johnson’s.

The Times cartoonist had clearly prepared his material so it could be flipped, either way, depending on the actual result. And by 323 votes, Labour retained the seat vacated by Tracy Brabin who had stood down when she was elected as the regional mayor for West Yorkshire.


By-elections are strange events –constituencies dominate national news briefly before sinking back into the comfortable normality of everyday life. Sadly, the good people of Batley and Spen may feel they have had more than their fair share of them.

The murder of Labour MP Jo Cox precipitated the first in 2016. She was a charismatic young woman – respected in parliament and loved in the constituency – who had been elected for just one year before her savage murder by a far-right extremist. It was her sister Kim Leadbeater who stood for Labour in this latest by-election.

Jo’s defining speech in the House of Commons concluded with the words, “we have more in common than divides us”.

It forms the motto on the plaque in the Commons Chamber above where she once sat. Sadly, that legacy was not honoured by her sister’s by-election campaign.

The arrival of George Galloway as a candidate for the seat ensured that. His campaign aides appear never to have heard the maternal dictum, “if you can’t say something nice, say nothing at all”.

They spread a toxic cocktail of homophobia, grievances over conflicts from the Middle East to Kashmir, and a direct invitation to oust Starmer as Labour leader.

Galloway’s message was a sectarian one that focused on the Muslim community and pitched it directly against the Labour party it had previously largely supported.

Having just lost the Hartlepool seat, Batley and Spen was now touted as a defining challenge to Labour’s leader. A seat that the party had won in every election since 1997, Batley and Spen was to be retained at all costs, it seems. But that cost came too high. Labour won the by-election, but the party lost its way.

When the Conservatives played divisive politics and Labour’s London mayor Sadiq Khan was targeted with vile anti-Muslim messages circulated in Hindu WhatsApp groups, Labour’s response was to seize the moral high ground, to focus on the issues of housing, police and transport, and to refuse to respond in kind. That was the right way to handle sectarianism.

In Batley and Spen, those in charge of Labour’s campaign made the opposite and disastrous choice. They descended into the gutter of sectarianism and put out a leaflet urging Islamic voters not to risk an MP “who is not on your side”.

The photograph of Johnson shaking hands with India’s prime minister Narendra Modi and the text which accompanied it specifically referred to human rights abuses in Kashmir.

That leaflet did not win Batley and Spen for Labour. What won was the strength and guts of Leadbeater who had stood up to one of Galloway’s henchmen on camera and made him look like the misogynistic bully he was. She is a local woman respected in the town and liked by local women who go to her pilates fitness classes. Leadbeater won Batley and Spen; Labour did not.

The Labour campaign managers allowed the short-term need to shore up Starmer’s leadership to outrank our party policy. That policy is clear – Kashmir is an exclusively bilateral matter for India and Pakistan to resolve, and should not be imported into politics in the UK to divide communities on sectarian lines. Policy should always outrank politicking, not the other way round.

The Labour Friends of India immediately condemned the leaflet and demanded it be withdrawn. That was the right thing to do. I have called on the general secretary of the party to repudiate the leaflet. That would be the right thing for him to do.

As for Starmer’s leadership, the national press have run with the headline ‘Labour is back’ and it looks secure. But he should acknowledge that the Batley and Spen leaflet was a mistake; that it was against party policy and that such divisive politics is and was indefensible.

True leadership is about more than winning by-elections. It is about having the moral authority that comes from knowing what your principles are and standing by them.

More For You

Will government inaction on science, trade & innovation cost the UK its economic future?

The life sciences and science tech sectors more widely continue to see out migration of companies

iStock

Will government inaction on science, trade & innovation cost the UK its economic future?

Dr Nik Kotecha OBE

As the government wrestles with market backlash and deep business concern from early economic decisions, the layers of economic complexity are building.

The Independent reported earlier in January on the government watchdog’s own assessment of the cost of Brexit - something which is still being fully weighed up, but their estimates show that “the economy will take a 15 per cent hit to trade in the long term”. Bloomberg Economics valued the impact to date (in 2023) at £100bn in lost output each year - values and impact which must be read alongside the now over-reported and repetitively stated “black hole” in government finances, being used to rationalise decisions which are already proving damaging.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Peace in Middle East hinges on Trump’s volatile decisions’

Israeli military vehicles stationed in Nabatieh, Lebanon, last Sunday (26)

‘Peace in Middle East hinges on Trump’s volatile decisions’

CAN the ceasefire endure for any significant length of time? This would go some way to ameliorating the incredible suffering in the region, but does it all hinge on one man, more than the future of the region has ever depended in its entire history?

Ceasefires can’t hold if no progress is made in addressing the underlying issues that led to the conflict in the first place.

Keep ReadingShow less
Deep love for laughter

Pooja K

Deep love for laughter

Pooja K

MY JOURNEY with comedy has been deeply intertwined with personal growth, grief, and selfdiscovery. It stems from learning acceptance and gradually rebuilding the self-confidence I had completely lost over the last few years.

After the sudden and tragic loss of my father to Covid, I was overwhelmed with grief and depression. I had just finished recording a video for my YouTube channel when I received the devastating news. That video was part of a comedy series about how people were coping with lockdown in different ways.

Keep ReadingShow less
UK riots

Last summer’s riots demonstrated how misinformation and inflammatory rhetoric, ignited by a tiny minority of extremists, can lead to violence on our streets

Getty Images

‘Events in 2024 have shown that social cohesion cannot be an afterthought’

THE past year was marked by significant global events, and the death and devastation in Ukraine, the Middle East and Sudan – with diplomatic efforts failing to achieve peace – have tested our values.

The involvement of major powers in proxy wars and rising social and economic inequalities have deepened divisions and prolonged suffering, with many losing belief in humanity. The rapid social and political shifts – home and abroad – will continue to challenge our values and resilience in 2025 and beyond.

Keep ReadingShow less
Values, inner apartheid, and diet

The author at Mandela-Gandhi Exhibition, Constitution Hill, Johannesburg, South Africa (December 2024)

Values, inner apartheid, and diet

Dr. Prabodh Mistry

In the UK, local governments have declared a Climate Emergency, but I struggle to see any tangible changes made to address it. Our daily routines remain unchanged, with roads and shops as crowded as ever, and life carrying on as normal with running water and continuous power in our homes. All comforts remain at our fingertips, and more are continually added. If anything, the increasing abundance of comfort is dulling our lives by disconnecting us from nature and meaningful living.

I have just spent a month in South Africa, visiting places where Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela lived, including the jails. They both fought against the Apartheid laws imposed by the white ruling community. However, no oppressor ever grants freedom to the oppressed unless the latter rises to challenge the status quo. This was true in South Africa, just as it was in India. Mahatma Gandhi united the people of India to resist British rule for many years, but it was the threat posed by the Indian army, returning from the Second World War and inspired by the leadership of Subhas Chandra Bose, that ultimately won independence. In South Africa, the threat of violence led by Nelson Mandela officially ended Apartheid in April 1994, when Mandela was sworn in as the country’s first Black president.

Keep ReadingShow less