Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

‘Leaders must offer vision for diverse and confident society’

Braverman’s migration speech was political theatre, says expert

‘Leaders must offer vision for diverse and confident society’

IS BRITAIN “a fantastic multicultural democracy” emerging as a role model of how to make diversity work? Or do a toxic combination of immigration and multiculturalism pose an existential threat to our social fabric and survival as a democratic nation?

Both arguments were advanced from the senior echelons of government over the last week – with Prime Minister Rishi Sunak offering a more optimistic take when asked about Home Secretary Suella Braverman’s headline-grabbing speech to a Washington thinktank.


The home secretary offered the most pessimistic language about British society of any government minister in the half century since Enoch Powell prophesied ‘Rivers of Blood’, leading to his sacking from the opposition front bench.

But how seriously should the Braverman speech be taken?

Braverman was not taken seriously enough by those liberal critics who focused more on her identity than her argument. The case that the Home Secretary cannot critique multiculturalism because she is a “product of multiculturalism” is incoherent.

Multiculturalism means different things to different people, including to the children and grandchildren of migrants. That some British Asians are very right-wing, even if most are not,  should hardly still be news these days.

It is legitimate to scrutinise the formative experiences of any politician – how their family, education and upbringing have shaped their worldview – but it is both questionable in principle and invariably counter-productive in practice for critics of a political opponent to focus on their fixed characteristics over their argument.

GettyImages 1255033559 Braverman's speech is a devastating critique of the potential consequences of the government’s failure to meet its pledges to stop the boats, says Katwala (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)

“If Braverman is wrong, let her at least be wrong for her own reasons,” wrote Trevor Phillips.

Yet, given this due respect of engaging with her argument, the Braverman speech crumbles badly. Her call for reforming the international refugee treaties is rhetorical. The UK government has no serious diplomatic push to pursue what would be a decade-long multilateral reform agenda, even if populist leaders in Italy, Poland and Hungary sympathise. Debating how to tighten the asylum criteria fits oddly with government policy – which is to reject all claims, if people arrive without permission, including those who would have valid claims to refugee status.

Braverman’s speech was largely understood in Westminster as a marker for a future Conservative leadership contest. That cynical view is probably accurate. Braverman holds one of the Great Offices of State, but her form of rhetorical populism would suit opposition politics more than government.

Taken seriously, the Braverman speech is a devastating critique of the potential consequences of the government’s failure to meet its pledges to stop the boats – while doubling down on impossible pledges to remove all asylum seekers.

LEAD Comment option 1B GettyImages 1592316251 Multiculturalism means different things to different people, including to the children and grandchildren of migrants, says Katwala (Photo by HENRY NICHOLLS/AFP via Getty Images)

The political stakes on asylum are high enough. It must be unwise to raise them further by conflating the asylum headache with the scale of legal migration arising from the government’s post-Brexit choices, and even the future of diversity and democracy in Britain.

Braverman’s critique of multiculturalism amounted to little more than a few throwaway soundbites. Declaring its failure to be visible from Leicester to Paris imagines the false premise of a shared British-French multiculturalism. Yet no two democracies have such starkly different philosophies and practices on the state’s response to diversity.

The logic of Braverman’s argument should lead her to praise France’s staunch rejection of multiculturalism. France has led on rhetorically championing French values, yet taking its race-blind universalism so far by banning the collection of ethnic data has left it with few tools for putting the vision into practice. Britain’s moderate multiculturalism outperformed France on serious efforts to audit progress, and ethnic minority confidence in feeling British too.

Yet the British record is mixed. Social confidence in our diversity has grown over time but has been unevenly spread, partly reflecting the uneven pattern of meaningful contact across generations and geography.

LEAD Comment Sunder Katwala byline pic 1 Sunder Katwala

For a quarter of a century, since the mill town disturbances of 2001, successive Prime Ministers have talked about the risks of not valuing integration and connection enough.

Thirteen years after David Cameron declared that multiculturalism was no longer the policy of the government, Braverman declared that she is against it too. Her speech was silent on what the post-multiculturalism agenda has been over the decade since, and how to develop it in future.

The green shoots of action plans, often in response to shock events, have not yet turned into a sustained strategy. Civic efforts to change that include a Together coalition call on party leaders, let by the Archbishop of Canterbury, to put the foundations in place to make social connection matter in the next parliament.

Politicians have argued about Britain’s diversity a lot. Braverman has shown again how easily a polarised debate gets stuck.

We need to hear more from political leaders, not just about what they are against but the vision of a more confident and socially connected Britain that they are for – and what they believe we can all do to pursue it.

More For You

SRH vs DC IPL 2025: The Ultimate Clash Between Hyderabad and Delhi

Both teams are coming off contrasting results in their previous games

Getty

IPL 2025 - SRH vs DC: Thrilling showdown between Hyderabad and Delhi awaits

The 10th match of IPL 2025 will see Delhi Capitals (DC) locking horns with Sunrisers Hyderabad (SRH) at the ACA-VDCA Cricket Stadium in Visakhapatnam on Sunday, March 30. Both teams are coming off contrasting results in their previous games, and this match promises to be a gripping contest, with several exciting player battles to watch out for.

Match overview

Delhi Capitals are fresh off a thrilling one-wicket win over Lucknow Super Giants. Chasing a formidable 210, DC's middle-order showed resilience, with Tristan Stubbs and Ashutosh Sharma forming a crucial 48-run partnership after an early collapse. Vipraj Nigam’s late cameo and Ashutosh’s calm composure at the death saw DC edge out a nail-biting finish with three balls to spare.

Keep ReadingShow less
RR vs CSK

Both teams coming off contrasting starts to their campaigns

Getty

IPL 2025 - RR vs CSK: Rajasthan takes on Chennai in high-stakes battle


The electrifying action of IPL 2025 continues as Rajasthan Royals (RR) lock horns with Chennai Super Kings (CSK) in match number 11 at the Barsapara Cricket Stadium in Guwahati on Sunday, March 30. With both teams coming off contrasting starts to their campaigns, this clash promises to be a thrilling battle of experience, skill, and determination.

Keep ReadingShow less
Reconnecting with lost Eid traditions

Bring the past into the present for a richer celebration

Reconnecting with lost Eid traditions

EID is a joyous time filled with unity, reflection, and celebration.

While the essence of the celebration has remained unchanged across centuries, the way this special day is celebrated has evolved, with many older traditions being replaced by modern practices and technological advancements.

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Tate Sued by Ex-Girlfriend Brianna Stern Over Sexual Assault Allegations

Tate’s attorney, Joseph McBride, has dismissed the lawsuit

Getty

Andrew Tate faces sexual assault lawsuit from ex-girlfriend Brianna Stern

Social media personality Andrew Tate is facing a new lawsuit from his ex-girlfriend, Brianna Stern, who has accused him of sexual assault, battery, and gender violence. The lawsuit, filed in Los Angeles, details allegations of abuse and an incident that allegedly took place at The Beverly Hills Hotel on 11 March 2025.

Allegations in the lawsuit

According to the legal complaint, Stern claims that Tate initially appeared as a "dream come true" but later became emotionally and physically abusive. The lawsuit describes a violent encounter at the hotel, where she alleges Tate physically assaulted and threatened her.

Keep ReadingShow less
Voices of Faith 2025: A journey through spirituality and wisdom

Soumik Datta (R) and Gurdain Singh Rayatt

Voices of Faith 2025: A journey through spirituality and wisdom

Mahesh Liloriya

The inaugural edition of Voices of Faith commenced on Friday at the iconic Barbican Centre, Silk Street, London, marking the beginning of an extraordinary three-day festival exploring theological philosophies, interfaith dialogues, and the deeper essence of spirituality through conversations, music, and healing vibes.

Organised by Teamwork Arts, the creators of the Jaipur Literature Festival (JLF) and JLF London, Voices of Faith is presented by the Kamini and Vindi Banga Family Trust, with the support of Tech Mahindra. Eastern Eye and Garavi Gujarat serve as the official media partners of this landmark event. This unique festival seeks to offer insights into navigating the complexities of modern life through the timeless wisdom enshrined in global religious traditions. It focuses on the universal ideals of compassion and interconnectedness that underpin the world’s faiths, fostering dialogue that transcends barriers and deepens mutual understanding.

Keep ReadingShow less