EMILY SPURRELL, the elected police and crime commissioner for Merseyside in north-western England, has said the force is “institutionally racist” and called for admitting the generic bias to mend its ways.
However, the Labour politician said she did not mean individual officers were racist but referred to the force as a whole.
Her comment follows the recommendations made by the Independent Office for Police Conduct to have safeguards from the stop and search powers to ensure that they are not disproportionately used against people of ethnic minority backgrounds.
Spurrell said in a TV interview that “the sooner we just accept” the existence of generic bias against black and ethnic minorities, “we can move on to putting it right”.
“The definition of institutional racism is not about calling individual officers racist. It’s about saying, as an institution — like with lots of institutions across the country — it has been designed by a certain group of people, and it does not take into account how black and ethnic minority people might experience things and how they might get treated.”
However, the chief constable of Merseyside police, Serena Kennedy, flatly refuted Spurrell’s claim.
"I categorically do not believe that Merseyside police is institutionally racist,” Kennedy said, while also maintaining that policing “is not free of racial discrimination”.
"The history and impact of racism across policing and the harm this has caused to communities and colleagues is clear. There has been a lot of work done nationally and locally to understand and address this. We know that policing, like society, is not free of racial discrimination, bias and disproportionality. It still exists in some policies and processes, and we are taking action to change this. We collectively want to improve, we want to progress, (and) we want to be better. We are not institutionally racist,” she said in a statement on Wednesday (4)
"There has been a lot of work done to understand how we need to change, and progress has been made but we know we need to do more, and we are committed to this”.
Kennedy said the National Race Action Plan, developed by the College of Policing and the National Police Chiefs' Council will set out the vision that policing “will be actively anti-racist and the work needed to achieve this”.
The local police federation also dismissed Spurrell's observation, saying it was “deeply disappointing”.
Site Navigation
Search
AI Powered
Human content,
AI powered search.
Latest Stories
Start your day right!
Get latest updates and insights delivered to your inbox.
Related News
More For You
Exclusive: 'Starmer must fill NHS staffing defecit'
Jan 10, 2025
LABOUR's latest announcement to cut NHS waiting lists, while welcome, does not go far enough, the former leader of the doctors’ union, Chaand Nagpaul has told Eastern Eye.
Prime minister, Sir Keir Starmer, unveiled his plans on Monday (6). He pledged Labour would set up more NHS hubs in community locations in England, and the service would make greater use of the private sector to help meet the challenge.
Starmer also promised that patients would have more choice over where they were treated.
“The government rightly needs to ensure that we have a health service that can provide care in a timely manner,” said Nagpaul.
“The waits that patients are suffering, and what I see every day as a GP are unacceptable.
“In fact, the NHS is not delivering on its objective to provide comprehensive, accessible care.
“The announcement will only make a very small difference in relative terms to the scale of waits that are currently being endured by patients in the NHS.”
Waiting lists
According to the government, 7.5 million people are on waiting lists, and more than 3 million have waited longer than its 18-week target.
“Those patients aren't being addressed by this initiative, which is really for prospective referrals,” the former chair of the British Medical Association (BMA) said.
“Those patients are coming to my practice every day, asking can their care be expedited, when will they be seen?
“That's actually not been addressed in these announcements.”
One of Nagpaul’s biggest concerns is the shortage of health care staff, which he described as “woeful”.
'Sorting out the lack of social care in the community needs to be a priority'
“We have around 50,000 fewer doctors in the UK compared to many European counterparts, and you can't have clinicians in two places at once.
“So, if you're really going to be expanding care into new centres they need to be staffed, and none of that was described in the announcement.”
The NHS also lacked proper infrastructure, he said.
“We need to look at the fact that we don't have enough hospital beds in this country, about a third the number of hospital beds in other countries like Germany.
“So, we can't actually provide the volume of care that should be the case in a nation like the UK.
“If you actually start to talk in terms of the infrastructure being corrected, that infrastructure will have a cost associated [with it].
“Rather than talk about money, what we should talk about is the practicalities of having the infrastructure to actually cope with this expanded level of care that we need to clear the backlog.”
- YouTubeyoutu.be
Social care
Nagpaul is a board member on the NHS Race & Health Observatory.
NHS England set up this independent body to tackle health inequalities experienced by communities of colour.
The “elephant in the room”, Nagpaul told Eastern Eye, was lack of social care for patients.
“One of the greatest contributors to the delays in patients being able to access hospital care is the fact that large numbers of patients are firstly occupying hospital beds and cannot be discharged because there aren’t the facilities in the community.
“As a GP, I can tell you many patients who are discharged, because the pressures in hospitals, are often readmitted because of lack of care in the community.
“Many patients end up quite unwell, they may fall, they may not be able to cope at home because of weakness and not having anyone to care for them, and the default then becomes an ambulance taking them to hospital.
“So, we really need to get social care sorted today.”
Last week (3), the government said it would review adult social care in England. Baroness Louise Casey will chair this independent inquiry, which begins in April.
But it will not publish its final report until 2028.
One key problem which Nagpaul has identified is that the different public services which look after patients do not work together.
“It doesn't make sense that a community nurse, who sees one of my patients, goes so far and says now you need to see someone else from a different system to come in again, to do their bit, which is around making sure that the home is safe for that patient to live in,” he explained.
“These things should be integrated as a seamless approach.
“Patients are caught in the crossfire between social care and the NHS, that needs to be tackled.
“Maybe that should be something the review should definitively look at, because this has dogged our health and care system for decades.
“The issue is this separation of social care and the NHS, because they are funded and operate in such a different way.”
Keep ReadingShow less
Most Popular
Calls grow for Lisa Nandy to end Telegraph ownership stalemate
Jan 10, 2025
THE SALE of The Telegraph newspaper has drawn widespread political calls for culture secretary Lisa Nandy to intervene and end the prolonged uncertainty surrounding its ownership.
The newspaper has been in limbo for 20 months after an auction process initiated by RedBird IMI, an Abu Dhabi-backed investment fund, failed to secure a suitable buyer.
RedBird IMI had sought to recover over £500 million spent in a deal to acquire the paper from the Barclay family, The Telegraph reported.
The sale process, overseen by investment bankers including former chancellor George Osborne, has been dubbed “the newspaper auction from hell” by the Columbia Journalism Review.
A potential bid by Dovid Efune, publisher of the New York Sun website, has stalled due to insufficient funding. Other interested parties, such as Lord Saatchi, David Montgomery, Paul Marshall, and Todd Boehly, have yet to meet RedBird IMI’s valuation.
Senior politicians across party lines have called for swift resolution. Conservative Shadow Culture Secretary Stuart Andrew stated: “It was right the Tory government at the time scrutinised the takeover move for The Telegraph. Now is the time to ensure certainty for the publication.”
Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey urged action, saying, “The Government must now urgently get a move on and resolve this uncertainty – anything less would be simply unacceptable, and bad for British democracy.”
Labour MP James Frith emphasised the need for both speed and safeguarding media plurality, stating, “Speed alone mustn’t come at the expense of safeguarding the sustainability and plurality of our print media.”
The Telegraph has been managed by independent directors since Lloyds Banking Group seized it from the Barclays in 2023 over unpaid debts.
The culture secretary retains powers to refer the case to the Competition and Markets Authority, which could trigger an investigation into press freedom concerns linked to Abu Dhabi’s involvement, the newspaper reported.
A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said, “The Government is not involved in the sale process of The Telegraph at this stage. This is for RedBird IMI alone.”
Meanwhile, Nandy’s office stated she is prohibited from expressing a view on the case.
The uncertainty continues to weigh on the newspaper’s operations, with editor-in-chief Chris Evans admitting to staff: “There’s obviously a limit to what we can do in these circumstances.”
Keep ReadingShow less
Labour government reports highest illegal migrant removals since 2018
Jan 10, 2025
THE LABOUR government announced on Thursday that it had removed 16,400 illegal migrants since taking office in July, the fastest rate of removals since 2018.
On taking office, prime minister Keir Starmer scrapped the previous Conservative government's scheme to send migrants who arrive illegally to Rwanda, instead setting up a Border Security Command to crack down on illegal migration – a huge political issue in Britain.
The new system prioritises dismantling the people-smuggling networks that enable migrants to cross into Britain using small boats. It also emphasises detaining and removing individuals living illegally in the country.
“Our message to those wanting to come here illegally is clear – you are wasting your money putting your trust in these vile gangs and will be returned swiftly,” Starmer said in a statement.
The government is also planning to introduce a sanctions regime aimed at leaders of smuggling networks responsible for bringing tens of thousands of people into the country annually.
According to government data, over 36,800 people crossed the Channel in 2024, a 25 per cent increase compared to the previous year. Dozens of migrants have died attempting the journey.
Since the Labour government came to power, enforced returns of illegal migrants have risen by 24 per cent year-on-year. The removals include 2,580 foreign nationals convicted of crimes.
(With inputs from Reuters)
Keep ReadingShow less
Two men jailed for trying to smuggle migrants into UK
Jan 09, 2025
TWO London-based men have been sentenced to over 10 years behind bars after being convicted of breaching UK immigration law by trying to smuggle four Indian migrants in a hidden van compartment disguised by a stack of dirty tyres.
According to the UK Home Office, British nationals Shafaz Khan and Choudhry Rashied, who operated under the alias ‘Manzar Mian Attique’, hid the group of migrants behind the tyres in a “purpose built” hidden space in the vehicle.
The pair were sentenced at Isleworth Crown Court in London on Tuesday (7) and each faces five years and three months in prison for facilitating a breach of UK immigration law.
“This case displays the lengths people smugglers will go to to disguise their criminal activity. These smugglers exploited a group of individuals by putting them into an unsafe and unlawful situation for their own financial gain,” said Dame Angela Eagle, UK minister for border security and asylum.
“Our skilled investigators are working tirelessly to protect our borders as part of our Plan for Change and that starts with dismantling the people smuggling networks who put lives at risk and undermine our border security. Alongside the major step up in enforcement action and integral cooperation with key partners we are also investing GBP 150 million of funding into our new Border Security Command to disrupt the criminal smuggling gangs profiting from risking lives,” she said.
The sentencing followed a Home Office investigation that revealed the men hired the van solely for the purpose of people smuggling. They were also found responsible for building the "hide", which was used to conceal the group of migrants.
"Phone analysis revealed the gang had assigned ‘burner’ phones to each other to help conceal their crimes, whilst CCTV traced the pair to a local cafe where they met to plan the illegal facilitation," the Home Office said.
The pair’s "dangerous operation" was shut down when they were stopped by UK Border Force officers at Newhaven Ferry Port on the south coast of England. Khan is said to have told the officers that they were travelling back from Belgium and the rear of their van contained used tyres.
But when officers searched the back of the van, they got more than they bargained for, with a group of migrants discovered in squalid and dangerous conditions hidden behind the heavy tyres with no access to clean air, the Home Office said.
Chris Foster, UK’s Immigration Enforcement Regional Lead, added: “Both Khan and Rashied sold these vulnerable individuals a dream and promised them a safe journey and prosperous life in the UK, which was far from the truth. The people smuggling gangs are playing with people’s lives and undermining our border security, we will not just watch on.
“We are stepping up our enforcement efforts to break the business model of the criminal networks that operate in the UK and Europe. Today’s sentencing sends a clear message to the criminals, if you get involved in people smuggling, you’re likely to spend a lengthy time behind bars.”
He went on to pay tribute to the hard work and tireless efforts of his team to take down the criminal gangs who “profit from this evil trade”.
(PTI)
Keep ReadingShow less
Four Indians accused of Nijjar’s murder granted bail in Canada
Jan 09, 2025
ALL four Indian nationals accused of murdering Khalistani separatist leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar have been granted bail by a court in Canada.
The accused, identified as Karan Brar, Amandeep Singh, Kamalpreet Singh, and Karanpreet Singh, face charges of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder.
The case, which has drawn international attention, will now proceed at the British Columbia Supreme Court, with the next hearing scheduled for 11 February 2025, as reported by India Today.
Nijjar, a prominent pro-Khalistan leader, was killed in Surrey, British Columbia, in June 2023. His assassination became the focus of a diplomatic row after Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau accused the Indian government of involvement. India has strongly denied these allegations, labelling them as "baseless."
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) arrested the four accused in May 2024 from different locations across Canada. However, delays in evidence presentation by the prosecution during preliminary hearings led to their release under a "stay of proceedings" while awaiting trial. Court records indicate that all four are "not" in custody, meaning they are either out on bail or released under specific conditions.
The Canadian government has employed a "direct indictment," expediting the case to trial by transferring it from Surrey Provincial Court to British Columbia Supreme Court.
A publication ban, requested by the Crown and agreed upon by defence counsel, restricts updates on pre-trial proceedings.
A Prosecution Service official confirmed that pre-trial motions will take place before the trial, but no timeline has been provided.
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More
© Copyright 2025 Garavi Gujarat Publications Ltd & Garavi Gujarat Publications