Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Comment: How migration matters in Labour’s economic plans

Government's policy choices will have a fiscal impact

Comment: How migration matters in Labour’s economic plans

The Starmer administration is using increasingly hawkish language on immigration

GOING for growth is a core mission for prime minister Sir Keir Starmer’s government.

So cutting the growth forecast for this year in half to one per cent was an inauspicious start to chancellor Rachel Reeves’ spring statement. The projection remains below two per cent through the parliament.


Anaemic growth made balancing the books a juggling act with fingers crossed. Painful cuts in welfare spending, particularly for people with disabilities, just about made the numbers add up enough – for now – for the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR) to give the chancellor a 50-50 chance of not needing more tax rises by the autumn budget.

But throw in US president Donald Trump as the disrupter unleashing trade wars from the White House, and that chance of a more benign scenario seems rose-tinted.

This government wants to protect spending on public services without more taxes or borrowing – while boosting defence spending too. The market and think-tank consensus is the chancellor was delaying acknowledging that this is now impossible.

The government proudly points to the pro-growth potential of its planning reforms. This will add 0.2 per cent to GDP growth by 2029. Less attention was paid to the role of immigration in the OBR calculations.

The OBR must work with the information that governments give it – adding a dash of political fiction to its otherwise painstaking work.

Former Conservative chancellor Jeremy Hunt gave himself permission to cut taxes by pencilling in unrealistically tight post-election spending plans. Hunt also took fiscal advantage of the Tories breaking their promise to cut immigration.

Home secretary Suella Braverman had resigned after a shouting match with Liz Truss and Hunt over their plan to “appease” the OBR with looser immigration rules. Braverman argued it was madness for Treasury models to show fiscal gains from higher immigration if the government wanted to cut it.

That is now a dilemma for Starmer’s Downing Street too. Net migration – having been 728,000 in the 12 months before the general election – fell significantly over the past nine months. The OBR estimates a potential trough at 258,000 before estimating net migration stabilising at around 340,000 for the rest of the parliament. That is politically rather higher than some key voices in Downing Street would feel comfortable with. Yet had they advised the OBR to anticipate a significantly lower level, they would already have knocked the chancellor’s fragile fiscal balancing act over.

Visa fees and charges now bring in about £6 billion to the Treasury coffers. In spring 2024, the OBR published how higher or lower migration scenarios would affect its fiscal model – but did not repeat the exercise this time. It had reported its estimate that reducing long-term net migration from 315,000 to 115,000 would cut tax receipts by £20bn, though the lower population could save £6bn on public services.

That would leave debt higher by £13bn – or 2.5 per cent of GDP. Charging £1,035 per visa as an NHS surcharge delivers more than £1.8bn for public services on top of what migrants pay in taxes too.

The Starmer government is using increasingly hawkish language on immigration. Yet the chancellor’s difficulty in sticking to her fiscal rules will significantly constrain the pace at which this government could reduce immigration further, even if the impact of higher migration on GDP per capita is somewhat marginal.

This Labour administration has delivered its headline manifesto objective to reduce net migration – by halving the level it inherited.

One option could be to make its future message more about the case for control and choice, than about driving numbers down further. It has rejected pressure to set a net migration target.

The return to pre-2019 net migration levels of around 300,000 may become a probable norm for the rest of the parliament, reflecting the practical reality that the government now needs to balance the politics of immigration with the fiscal impact of its policy choices, as well as the labour market needs in the NHS and social care too.

An alternative approach would be to try to make immigration for work and study more selective. For example, while international graduates can stay and work for 24 months without restrictions, new conditions could include needing to secure a graduatelevel role after six or 12 months in order to stay longer. In principle, a more selective approach could deliver a better fiscal outcome for similar immigration levels, or try to gradually pursue a moderately lower level, perhaps net 200,000 to 250,000, without a fiscal penalty.

The Starmer government will never be able to compete in a rhetorical auction over who can say the lowest number. Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick wants to again propose the old “tens of thousands” target that the Conservatives always missed as a new legal limit. Reform leader Nigel Farage’s vision is that the right level of net migration would be zero.

The government’s white paper will make a case for controlling immigration. It may need to acknowledge the real world dilemmas of control too.

Sunder Katwala is the director of thinktank British Future and the author of the book How to Be a Patriot: The must-read book on British national identity and immigration

More For You

british-muslims

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

iStock)

Government announces fund to combat anti-Muslim hate

THE UK government has announced a new fund to monitor anti-Muslim hate and support victims, with applications opening on 7 April.

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

Keep ReadingShow less
Asian drug dealer known as 'starkcake' jailed for 18 years

Heemal Vaid (Photo: NCA)

Asian drug dealer known as 'starkcake' jailed for 18 years

A 49-year-old Asian drug dealer who masterminded the import and sale of cocaine and heroin worth more than £4 million has been jailed for 18 years, after National Crime Agency (NCA) investigators identified him from secret phone messages.

British Indian Heemal Vaid, of Cheam, used EncroChat – an encrypted phone service for criminals – to broker deals, unaware that in 2020, an international law enforcement team would crack EncroChat’s encryption.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump

Trump announced a series of tariff increases targeting various nations, including key US allies such as the UK and the European Union.

Getty Images

Trump’s tariffs hit global markets, Starmer warns of 'economic impact'

The UK and other global economies reacted on Thursday to US president Donald Trump's newly imposed tariffs, with prime minister Keir Starmer warning of an “economic impact” from the 10 per cent levy on British exports.

Trump announced a series of tariff increases targeting various nations, including key US allies such as the UK and the European Union.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sri Lanka forms committee to address UK sanctions
Anura Kumara Dissanayake

Sri Lanka forms committee to address UK sanctions

THE Sri Lanka government on Wednesday (2) formed a committee to recommend measures regarding the UK's decision to impose sanctions on three former military commanders who led the campaign that crushed the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) in 2009.

Health minister Nalinda Jayatissa told reporters that foreign minister Vijitha Herath, justice minister Harshana Nanayakkara and deputy minister of defence Aruna Jayasekara would comprise the committee that would consult experts for the purpose.

Keep ReadingShow less
UK Introduces Digital Entry Permit for European Visitors

The ETA can be purchased online for £10 (12 euros), but the cost will rise to £16 from 9 April. (Representational image: Reuters)

Reuters

European visitors to UK will now need digital entry permit

FROM WEDNESDAY, European visitors to the UK will need an online entry permit as part of new travel requirements introduced by the British government.

The Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA), a digital permit, will be required for travellers from Europe. UK officials say the move aims to enhance border security and simplify entry procedures.

Keep ReadingShow less