Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Mixed reaction to sentences in recent cases involving Asians

By Amit Roy

BORIS JOHNSON is said to be toying with the idea of fixing the legal system so judges in future will no longer have jurisdiction over decisions taken by (Tory) governments, such as prorogation of parliament.


That seems the slippery slope towards becoming a banana republic.

Meanwhile, justice, dispensed by independent judges, magistrates and tribunals, should not only be seen to be done but also ensure punishments are proportionate to the crime.

Should Shamima Begum be allowed back? Since she has lost all her children, I probably would readmit her on humanitarian grounds, but she left in 2015 to join Daesh (Islamic State) of her own free will when she was a 15-year-old schoolgirl. So I can see why the government wants to use her as a warning to others.

She has just lost the first stage of her appeal, with the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) ruling that she will not be rendered stateless because Shamima, though UK born, is “a citizen of Bangladesh by descent”.

The reality is that the girl from Bethnal Green has never set foot in Bangladesh, which has announced she will be “hanged” if she does. Under this ruling, dozens of home-grown terrorists and members of grooming gangs could also be considered “citizens of Pakistan by descent” and deported.

It is hard to quibble with the three life sentences given to the Indian origin GP, Manish Shah, 50, who will have to serve at least 15 years for 90 sex offences against 24 female patients.

He cited the cancer cases of Angelina Jolie and Jade Goody to trick 24 women into unnecessary and invasive tests.

Quoting one of his victims, the judge Anne Molyneux QC told him: “You made up stories which got into heads and caused panic.”

Perhaps most intriguing is the decision by Citigroup to suspend Paras Shah, 31, a million-pounds-ayear trader, allegedly for pinching sandwiches from the office canteen in Canary Wharf.

The trader, who lives in north London with his wife, Aarti, would not open his front door to even his cousin, Dinesh, who revealed Paras was especially fond of cheese and pickle sandwiches.

In the Financial Times (FT), Henry Mance wondered: “Is Citi mad? The trader was rumoured to be highly successful. A minor larceny would have been dwarfed by his morning’s profits.

“What about the employees who take Biros from the office stationery cupboard? ….. Are we – I mean, they – all to be fired? Sadly, it pains me to conclude that Citigroup was probably in the right.” Matthew Vincent asked, also in the FT: “Was Citigroup trader’s sandwich the costliest City lunch?”

He recalled: “Until this week, the record for most costly City lunch was arguably shared by ravenous financiers from Barclays and RBS. In 2001, dealmakers at Barclays Capital spent £44,007 on a celebratory meal, including £12,300 for a bottle of 1947 Petrus and £9,200 for a 1900 château d’Yquem …Five of the six diners paid with their jobs.

“Then, in 2008, RBS bankers were persuaded to manipulate interest rates by offers of ‘steak’ and ‘sushi rolls from yesterday’. RBS paid $325m [£252m] to settle with US regulators.

“But this appetite for risk and day-old fish must now be compared with that of Citigroup bond trader Paras Shah, whose alleged theft of canteen food has led to his suspension from a £1m-plus job. His colleagues tell City Insider he took selfservice a tad too literally on ‘a few occasions’. But Citi’s HR department might wish to put it in perspective, as Twitter user @thecdstrader did: ‘Historic banking losses: 1995 Barings, $1.3bn [£1bn]on Nikkei options... 2008 SocGen, $8bn [£6.2bn] on equity index... 2019 Citi, £4.50 on a cheese sandwich.’”

Maybe Citigroup should reinstate Paras, but halve his salary and tell him to bring his own sandwiches from home.

More For You

Comment: Reform split exposes the dangers of unchecked populist rhetoric

Reform UK's new MPs Richard Tice, Nigel Farage, Lee Anderson and Rupert Lowe pose during a presentation of their programme in London on July 5, 2024

Getty Images

Comment: Reform split exposes the dangers of unchecked populist rhetoric

IT took Nigel Farage 30 years to get elected as an MP until the voters of Clacton sent him to the Commons on his eighth attempt last summer. Having broken through by getting five Reform MPs, Farage has taken every opportunity to stoke the media hype in which supporters fantasise and his critics fear a populist wave could sweep him all the way into Downing Street next time. But there has been something of a reality check this month – with the new party splitting as relationships broke down between the leader and Rupert Lowe, the former Southampton FC chairman elected in Great Yarmouth.

The Farage-Lowe battle has many dimensions. It can be seen as a personality clash of political egos – which escalated after US billionaire businessman, Elon Musk, decided he preferred Lowe to Farage. It is an argument about Farage’s control of Reform’s structures – and the slow progress in giving party members any role. The Reform leadership says it is about personal conduct – even reporting Lowe to the police for alleged threats to party chair Zia Yusuf – but acted against Lowe only when he criticised the leader.

Keep ReadingShow less
Essence of Ramadan

Ramadan is a time for self-reflection and to become better human beings

Essence of Ramadan

THE word Ramadan conjures images of fasting, shared meals, and a sense of community, but there is a deeper, more profound purpose beneath the surface of this holy month for Muslims.

Ramadan is not just about abstaining from food and drink; it is a transformative journey of self-discovery, offering a chance to shed old habits and cultivate inner peace. It is a month of selfreflection, a time to become better human beings and reconnect with our values.

Keep ReadingShow less
Asian health workers paid
heavy price during Covid

The National Covid Memorial Wall on the Covid-19 Day of Reflection, marking five years since the start of the pandemic in London last Sunday (9)

Asian health workers paid heavy price during Covid

BEREAVED families and friends came together last Sunday (9) to remember the loss of loved ones as the UK marked five years since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Public memory is remarkably short; there was a time when people were prevented from even saying goodbye to their relatives as they died in hospital. To prevent contamination, their bodies were slipped into body bags for funerals where almost no one could come.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sunak symbolised how high
ethnic minority talent can rise

Rishi Sunak and his wife Akshata Murty

Sunak symbolised how high ethnic minority talent can rise

“MY POLITICAL journey was so quick,” former prime minister Rishi Sunak told Nick Robinson during a two-hour BBC podcast on his lessons from Downing Street.

Sunak’s meteoric rise and demise makes him a former prime minister at 44. Was it too much, too young? Did he make a mistake in grabbing a couple of years as prime minister after the implosion of Liz Truss?

Keep ReadingShow less
Are Tamil cinema’s big stars failing the industry?
Indian 2

Are Tamil cinema’s big stars failing the industry?

BOLLYWOOD’S recent string of big box of fice disasters has been well-documented, but Tamil cinema is also experiencing a tough period.

The industry, known as Kollywood, had one of its worst years in 2024, with a jaw dropping amount of money being lost on big-budget blockbusters that were rejected by audiences. Although there were a few successes, like Amaran and Maharaja, 2024, just like previous years, was dominated by expensive flops headlined by big-name stars that didn’t live up to expectations.

Keep ReadingShow less