Skip to content
Search
Please enter at least 3 characters.

Latest Stories

REVEALED: “WHISTLE BLOWER” JUDGE JOINS JUDICIARY COMMITTEE

REVEALED: “WHISTLE BLOWER” JUDGE JOINS JUDICIARY COMMITTEE

Following an Eastern Eye campaign, we reveal latest on “secret” whistleblowing plan

Exclusive


A JUDGE who won a seven-year legal battle to allow her reveal experience of bullying and racism in the judiciary has been “invited” to join a committee drawing up a whistle blowing policy.

This week (9), Eastern Eye revealed that District Judge Claire Gilham had not been consulted about the new guidelines.

The judicial office sacked Gilham after she complained publicly about the safety of courts, cuts in legal aid in family court cases, bullying and racism faced by judges, barristers and solicitors.

However, the Supreme Court ruled she was a worker and entitled to whistle blow.

This forced the judicial office and Ministry of Justice (MoJ) to create a policy, due to be published this month.

Speaking for the Judicial Support Network (JSN), Judge Kaly Kaul told Eastern Eye, “The Judicial Support Network is delighted that the lord chief justice has asked Judge Claire Gilham to join the whistleblowing committee, chaired by the Honourable Mrs Justice Jennifer Eady.

“Last week in a virtual meeting, the former President of the Supreme Court, Baroness Brenda Hale, was asked about judges’ rights. She said the Supreme Court had been pleased to recognise the rights of judges to seek to support the administration of justice by making protected disclosures.

“The JSN recognises that having been through her hard-fought legal victory to highlight court safety, legal aid funding, bullying and racism in our ranks, Judge Gilham will be a welcome addition to the Committee.”

Gilham did not comment on her appointment.

But she had previously told Eastern Eye, “I wouldn't have embarked upon the whistleblowing case that I did, spending so much of my family's resources and so many years of my life, taking the ministry to the Supreme Court to try and get whistleblowing rights for judges.

“The development of the required policy should be opening up the judiciary to public scrutiny and inducing transparency so that we can admit our mistakes.

“We need a policy which allows for a whistle blower to raise very serious concerns.”

‘Welcome news’

South Asian and black judges welcomed the news of her joining the committee.

“Unofficially, we call the policy ‘Claire's Law’,” said one. “She fought, single-handedly, for seven years to ensure that judges were recognised as workers and had the rights to whistle blow.

“It’s difficult to understand why the judiciary fought so hard, using tax payer money to resist the recognition of those rights, and not only failed to support her, but many denigrated her for standing up for the judges and sought to undermine her character.

“We owe her a huge debt of gratitude, as does the country.”

Post-traumatic stress disorder

Judges have told Eastern Eye the pressures they are under from “bullying presiders” who make their lives “a living hell”.

One ethnic minority judge, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said they were on anti-depressants and suffered post-traumatic stress disorder.

“I’ve lost all confidence, and I dare not complain because they are so vindictive,” they revealed.

“What no-one seems to understand is that if we aren’t protected, if we can’t speak out when things aren’t right, if we allow our independence to be taken away, because that’s what is creeping up on us, we can’t protect those coming before us.

“Everyone assumes judges are in their ivory towers, and we all work together in harmony. That is simply a fantasy. We have some real-world issues which need to be tackled, and I know if I made my feelings public, I’d be sacked from a job I love.”

Judges’ support

In March, circuit judge Kaly Kaul founded a support network for judges.

Eastern Eye understands that since the launch, judges have contacted the JSN asking for support and help.

“The JSN was set up to support and listen to any judges who feel sensitive matters need to be raised but feel unable to do so on their own,” Kaul said.

“It is important that we work together, for one another, and are champions who give a voice to those who feel unheard.”

Eastern Eye first revealed the culture of bullying, racism and fear in the judiciary last July.

“We’re grateful to Eastern Eye and the Solanki family [publishers of Eastern Eye] for having the courage to raise and support issues that are important to our community in the UK, and for the support it has shown for the interests of all minorities,” said one Asian judge.

Eastern Eye offered to help the lord chief justice and his office, as well as the justice select committee.

On the urging of judges, we asked for an independent inquiry which protects judges and allows them to give evidence.

So far, both bodies have refused to do so.

Next month, an employment tribunal will hear allegations of race discrimination, bullying and victimisation.

Peter Herbert, a retired part-time judge and recorder and former chair of the Black Society of Lawyers is taking on the MoJ.

“The system is conducted by people who have little or no willingness to challenge overt racism,” he told Eastern Eye in April.

“Systemic racism has to be confronted, and sadly, some of the most senior people, lord chief justice, and others do not see this as a major problem. And that's, in a sense, the heart of it.”

More For You

Aamir Khan

Aamir has always been known for taking bold and innovative approaches to his films

Getty images

Aamir Khan begins work on his ambitious 'Mahabharat' adaptation

Aamir Khan, one of Bollywood's most celebrated actors and filmmakers, has officially revealed that he has begun work on his long-awaited adaptation of the Mahabharat. For years, Aamir has expressed a deep passion for turning this legendary Indian epic into a film, and as he approached his 60th birthday, he has confirmed that work on this monumental project is finally underway.

Aamir Khan shares an exciting update

During a meet-and-greet with the paparazzi ahead of his milestone birthday, Aamir Khan gave fans the news they've been waiting for. When asked about his plans to adapt the Mahabharat for the big screen, he said, "I have just started. Just starting, putting the team together for the writing and all that, just started."

Keep ReadingShow less
Ibrahim Ali Khan’s fiery DM to Pakistani critic over ‘Nadaaniyan’ sparks social media uproar

Ibrahim Ali Khan’s fiery DM to Pakistani critic goes viral

Instagram/iakpataudi

Ibrahim Ali Khan’s fiery DM to Pakistani critic over ‘Nadaaniyan’ sparks social media uproar

Ibrahim Ali Khan has found himself at the centre of an online storm following his message to Pakistani film critic Tamur Iqbal. The critic had shared his blunt review of Ibrahim’s debut film Nadaaniyan, mocking not only the film but also taking a personal swipe at Ibrahim’s appearance. What followed was an angry message from the young actor that has since gone viral.

Tamur Iqbal had posted a story on Instagram, criticising Nadaaniyan for its performances and taking a dig at Ibrahim’s “huge nose.” While harsh reviews are common in the world of cinema, Ibrahim’s alleged reaction caught many by surprise. In a screenshot Tamur later shared publicly, Ibrahim appears to lash out, calling the critic “an ugly piece of trash” and threatening to “leave you uglier” if they crossed paths in person.

Keep ReadingShow less
Millie Bobby Brown

Millie Bobby Brown’s rise as Netflix’s ‘Stream Queen’ is a reflection of the current state of the film industry

Getty images

Millie Bobby Brown and the rise of cinema’s first ‘stream queen’ with 'The Electric State'

At just 21 years old, Millie Bobby Brown has already secured her place as a prominent figure in the entertainment industry. The star of Stranger Things, who first captivated audiences with her portrayal of Eleven, now finds herself at the forefront of Netflix’s most high-profile projects. However, her latest role in The Electric State, a mindbogglingly expensive Netflix sci-fi film, has sparked mixed reactions and raised questions about her trajectory as a ‘Stream Queen’ – a title that comes with both acclaim and criticism.

The Electric State, in which Brown stars alongside Chris Pratt, has not been warmly received by critics. Described by The Independent's Clarisse Loughrey as “punishingly obvious and completely incoherent,” the film’s one-star reviews have been echoed by many others. The movie, which centres around two hollow characters moving aimlessly through a barren plot, seems to be yet another forgettable venture in Brown’s recent streak of Netflix productions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Priyanka Chopra

Priyanka’s involvement in SS Rajamouli’s next film has been the talk of the town

Getty images

Priyanka Chopra celebrates Holi on the sets of SS Rajamouli’s film 'SSMB29', shares images

Priyanka Chopra is back in India to celebrate one of the country’s most beloved festivals, Holi, and this time, she is combining work and festivity on the sets of her upcoming project with acclaimed filmmaker SS Rajamouli. The Bollywood star, who is known for her international fame and achievements, gave fans a sneak peek into her colourful Holi celebrations, sharing her joy and excitement about being part of such a massive project.

Priyanka Chopra’s Holi celebration on set

Taking to Instagram, Priyanka shared a few photos of her Holi celebrations on the sets of Rajamouli’s upcoming film. The images depicted her in a casual and light-hearted mood, her cheeks covered in vibrant hues of pink and orange, clearly embracing the spirit of the festival. She captioned the post, “It's a working Holi for us. Here's wishing everyone celebrating a very Happy Holi full of laughter and togetherness with your loved ones.”

Keep ReadingShow less