Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Revised health checks ‘could exclude Asians’

by LAUREN CODLING

SENIOR doctors have spoken of their concern for British Asian patients after the government decided to reconsider NHS health checks last Friday (16).


The checks are currently offered to UK patients aged between 40 and 74 to spot the early signs of life-threatening conditions such as kidney and heart disease and Type 2 diabetes.

However, the Department of Health and Social Care said the scheme pays little attention to people’s individual risks or needs.

Now the government is set to review the personalised health checks, with promises to introduce online checks and more “targeted” advice.

According to ministers, the latest review will focus on offering personalised interventions based on factors such as age, where people live and their DNA.

Health secretary Matt Hancock said the review would be an “important step” to move away from the “one-size-fits-all approach of the past”.

“(The review will help) us to find data-led, evidenced-based ways to support people to spot, manage and prevent risks to their health through targeted intervention,” Hancock said.

Speaking to Eastern Eye on Monday (19), Professor Mayur Lakhani welcomed the review,

but admitted he worried about how the changes could affect Asian patients.

Lakhani, who is the president of the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP), said he was particularly concerned about the notion of introducing online checks.

“Some Asian patients have language barriers and they also have lower usage of the internet, so inadvertently this could lead to inequalities,” he said.

Lakhani, who chaired the health secretary’s inquiry into primary care access for BAME patients in 2007, noted the importance of health care for Asian patients, referring to increased risks of heart problems and diabetes. If the care was primarily online, he worried that it could create a “two-tiered system”.

Although he stressed he did not believe that was the review’s intention, he hoped there would be further moves made to ensure some patients were not excluded.

“Let (patients) have a voice in this issue and for the review,” Lakhani said. “If British Asians experts or patient groups could be represented, then I think that would make it much more positive.”

In response to the news, the honorary vice-president of the British Medical Association (BMA), Dr Kailash Chand, revealed his cynicism relating to the health checks.

“Politicians love the idea because the thought of doing something ‘good’ has populist appeal, but most or all doctors believe that these ‘health checks’ are scientifically flawed while also being a bad idea,” Dr Chand told Eastern Eye.

“My experience of 30 years in general practice tells me you always find something

‘false positive’ or a ‘false negative’ that you can’t explain – then you do more tests.” He added: “An individual may end up with diagnoses of diseases or risk factors which wouldn’t have caused any symptoms in his lifetime. The screening results in over-diagnosis, over-treatment, benefiting pharmaceutical and insurance companies and not patients at all.”

Stressing his belief that “prevention is better than a cure”, Dr Chand suggested that funding be delegated to local initiatives which could make a difference.

“Asians who have lot more prevalence of diabetes and heart diseases could benefit from tailored lifestyle advice and access to local services, such as stop smoking services, and/or clinical management to help them reduce their heart disease and diabetes risk,” he said.

In response to Eastern Eye, the BMA GP committee chair, Dr Richard Vautrey, said the trade union welcomed the review.

However, he stressed that the government had to ensure that any future preventative care plans were tailored so that those population groups who were at most risk of preventable ill health got the care they needed as a priority.

Dr Vautrey added: “If the responsibility to carry out more advanced health checks lies within general practice, which we believe it should be, then the government must ensure that the appropriate resources and investment is in place so GPs can effectively oversee the delivery of this care.”

More For You

Gwyneth Paltrow

Paltrow's interest in wellness and food began in part due to her father’s battle with throat cancer

Getty

Gwyneth Paltrow returns to sourdough and pasta after years of ‘hardcore’ diets

Gwyneth Paltrow has revealed that she is returning to eating foods she once restricted, including sourdough bread, pasta, and cheese, after following a strict paleo diet for several years. The Oscar-winning actress, who has become a prominent health and wellness advocate, has been vocal about her diet choices throughout her career, particularly through her lifestyle business, Goop.

In a recent episode of her Goop podcast, Paltrow discussed her food journey and how her eating habits have evolved over the years. She explained that she had previously gone through a "hardcore macrobiotic" phase, describing it as an "interesting chapter" where she became deeply focused on eating extremely healthy foods. This period saw her embracing a diet rich in seasonal and local foods, with an emphasis on fish, vegetables, and rice, while eliminating dairy and sugar.

Keep ReadingShow less
5 Surprising Penguin Facts to Celebrate World Penguin Day

It’s a perfect opportunity to reflect on these fascinating facts about penguins

iStock

Top 5 fascinating facts about penguins on World Penguin Day

As World Penguin Day arrives, it serves as a reminder to celebrate one of nature’s most beloved and unique creatures. Penguins have long captured our imaginations with their tuxedo-like appearance, charming behaviour, and extraordinary ability to thrive in some of the harshest environments on Earth. While these remarkable birds are most closely associated with the icy expanses of Antarctica, their story is far more diverse and fascinating. Here are five fascinating facts about penguins that highlight their resilience, adaptability, and their role in the animal kingdom.

1. Penguins aren’t confined to Antarctica

Although penguins are often linked with the cold and icy landscapes of Antarctica, they are not confined to this frozen continent. In fact, penguins inhabit a wide range of environments across the Southern Hemisphere. While species such as the Emperor and Adélie penguins breed exclusively in Antarctica, other penguin species have adapted to life in warmer climates. For instance, the Galápagos penguin resides on the Galápagos Islands, located just north of the equator, where temperatures are much warmer than those in the icy waters of the South Pole.

Keep ReadingShow less
Harrogate flower show

Organised by the North of England Horticultural Society

Getty

Harrogate to host UK’s largest flower show with 40,000 visitors

An estimated 40,000 visitors are expected to attend the Harrogate Spring Flower Show over the next four days, making it one of the UK’s largest events for horticulture and floral art. The event, which opened today (Thursday 24 April), is being held at the Great Yorkshire Events Centre in Harrogate and runs daily from 9.30 am to 5 pm until Sunday 27 April.

Organised by the North of England Horticultural Society, the Harrogate Spring Flower Show is recognised for hosting the UK’s biggest exhibition of creative floral art. This year’s floral art theme, Swords & Sorcery: Fantasy Heroes, features imaginative displays inspired by fantasy and mythical tales.

Keep ReadingShow less
Asian community

Menopause is a universal transition - one every woman will experience in her lifetime

iStock

Breaking the silence: Why Asian women must talk about menopause

Kiran Singh

For many women in the Asian community, the journey through perimenopause and menopause is still shrouded in silence, confusion, and, at times, shame. It’s often seen as something we just have to “put up with” quietly, as though struggling through it alone is a badge of honour. But the truth is, menopause is a universal transition - one every woman will experience in her lifetime - and it is time we start talking about it, especially within our cultural communities where silence often masks suffering.

We all go through it - so why don’t we talk about it?

Menopause doesn’t arrive overnight. For most women, it begins subtly during perimenopause, which can start as early as your late 30s or early 40s and last for several years. According to the NHS and the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), over 30 recognised symptoms of perimenopause range from hot flushes and night sweats to anxiety, low mood, brain fog, and joint pain.

Keep ReadingShow less
How AI and music could transform dementia care for south Asians

AI tunes into dementia needs

How AI and music could transform dementia care for south Asians

THE recent World Health Congress Awards in Mumbai were a revelation. Stepping into that room overlooking the Arabian Sea, I was surrounded by pioneers and individuals shaping the future of healthcare with bold ideas.

Amid the buzz of innovation, one topic resonated deeply: dementia. It was not just the medical complexities, but the human stories, the silent struggles of carers, and the potential for technology to bridge the widening gaps in care.

Keep ReadingShow less