Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Sunder Katwala: Middle east conflict puts faith and society in the spotlight

‘The question of faith in British society often feels unsettled’

Sunder Katwala: Middle east conflict puts faith and society in the spotlight

FROM one perspective, it could seem difficult to find another major democracy that is quite as relaxed about the role of religious faith in public life as Britain is today. As Eid this week brought the month of Ramadan to a close for several million British Muslims, it will provide the latest occasion for the familiar ritual of political leaders sending warm greetings to the followers of each faith as they mark the special days of their religion. That long-standing tradition continues with the twist of a more diverse cast.

It is now a Hindu prime minister in Downing Street who tweets about what the sacrifice of Jesus Christ means to Christians, while the Muslim mayor of London, Sadiq Khan and first minister of Scotland, Humza Yousaf, host multi-faith iftars to break their own Ramadan fast while recognising Hindu and Christian festivals.


Sunder Katwala Sunder Katwala

These exchanges of faithful civilities capture our settled consensus on some foundational questions. Public life is certainly open to those of all faiths and none who will champion British values of the freedom of religious expression, and mutual respect for belief and non-belief.

Yet the question of faith in British society often feels unsettled too. The coincidence of Ramadan and Easter this year generated some vocal grievances about the public visibility of Islam. The GB News channel seemed to spend much of the Easter weekend complaining about too much recognition of Islam in a country with a Christian heritage – overlooking the BBC’s usual extensive programming of Christian services, songs and faith discussions – yet, did not seem to give any of its own airtime to discussing the Christian tradition itself rather than grievances about it being neglected by others.

Jews in Britain have faced rising antisemitism in recent months. Many Muslims experienced both solidarity and isolation during Ramadan this year. Iftar meals to break the fast have been held in a wider range of settings this year than ever before – from prominent football stadiums to synagogues, churches and workplaces. Imam Qari Asim of Leeds Makkah Mosque spoke of how heavily the loss of life in Gaza is weighing on the minds of his congregants: “For many, our own fleeting hunger pangs have been a reminder of the starving adults and children we can see on our screens, as we pray for their suffering to be alleviated”.

Julie Siddiqi of Together for Humanity told me that both Jews and Muslims have been feeling increasingly isolated and under pressure since the Middle East conflict escalated, sometimes in different ways: “Never in 25 years of community organising and interfaith work have I seen something happening abroad have such a huge impact on communities and individuals here.”

A recent headline-grabbing opinion poll, conducted by JL Partners for the Henry Jackson Society, contained worrying findings. Four out of ten Muslim respondents said they did not believe Hamas committed atrocities on October 7. Just three per cent of Muslim respondents sympathised with Daesh (Islamic State group), but attitudes to Hamas were much more ambivalent. Over a quarter (29 per cent) expressed sympathy. Yet having uncovered genuinely troubling levels of sympathy and fence-sitting, this survey appeared designed to spin-up support for Hamas as high as it could. Asking respondents to choose between Hamas and Israel – mirroring the framing a pro-Islamist propagandist would choose – doubled general public support for Hamas, to generate sensationalised headlines claiming that almost half of British Muslims, rather than a quarter, sympathise with Hamas.

So the survey design exemplifies why the Henry Jackson Society’s track record has left the pressure group with negligible trust across British Muslim civic society. The non-Muslim general public were asked about perceptions of anti-Muslim prejudice since October 7, but an editorial choice was made not to ask Muslim respondents anything about that. Instead, priority was given to asking them about outlawing homosexuality, making halal compulsory and even making Islam our state religion. If the full poll script reads like a long fishing trip to exaggerate differences between Muslims and their fellow citizens, sometimes bordering on trolling, it frequently failed to land what it was casting its net for. Removing the Established Church appeals to 18 per cent of the public and just 14 per cent of the Muslim respondents, for example.

If this Henry Jackson Society poll was an active demonstration of how to frame an argument to inflate support for Hamas in polarised times, its results offer insights for counter-extremism voices who want to marginalise extreme narratives, rather than boost them. Rejecting that binary frame, separating the cause of Palestine from Hamas and showing how one can recognise both the horrors of October 7 and of the civilian death toll in Gaza, will all matter if we are to get the boundaries right between politics and prejudice. The stakes are high, especially with young people for whom this conflict may be a formative experience. But it is vital for our plural society that we get this right.

More For You

Police Recover £1M Stolen Jewellery in Hounslow, Owners Sought

The jewellery was largely taken from London’s South Asian community in Hounslow between 2023 and 2024. (Photo: Met Police)

Stolen jewellery worth £1m recovered in Hounslow, police seek owners

POLICE are seeking to reunite stolen jewellery worth over £1 million with its rightful owners after recovering the items during a proactive operation across London and the home counties.

The recovered collection includes identifiable pieces such as a World War One officer’s Rolex watch, a gold locket containing old pictures, an engraved gold ring, and an engraved gold pocket watch from Harlow Bros Ltd.

Keep ReadingShow less
british-muslims

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

iStock)

Government announces fund to combat anti-Muslim hate

THE UK government has announced a new fund to monitor anti-Muslim hate and support victims, with applications opening on 7 April.

The initiative aims to track incidents, raise awareness of hate crime, and provide better victim support.

Keep ReadingShow less
Probe launched over racist broadcast at Kent asylum centre

FILE PHOTO: Entrance of Manston short-term holding centre for migrants, near Ramsgate in southeast England. (Photo by BEN STANSALL/AFP via Getty Images)

Probe launched over racist broadcast at Kent asylum centre

AUTHORITIES have launched an investigation following reports that a racist message was broadcast over portable radios at an asylum processing centre in Kent.

The incident occurred at the Manston site, where small boat arrivals are processed by the Home Office and its contractor, Mitie, reported The Guardian.

Keep ReadingShow less
Protest against dog crackdown ahead of Modi's Sri Lanka visit

Sri Lankan animal rights activists take part in a demonstration in Colombo on April 3, 2025, to protest the round-up of stray dogs a day ahead of a visit by Narendra Modi. (Photo by ISHARA S. KODIKARA/AFP via Getty Images)

Protest against dog crackdown ahead of Modi's Sri Lanka visit

SRI LANKAN animal rights activists marched on Thursday (3) to protest the round-up of stray dogs a day ahead of a visit by Indian prime minister Narendra Modi.

Authorities in Colombo and the Buddhist pilgrim city of Anuradhapura have reportedly deployed dog catchers to impound hounds ahead of Modi's visit, which begins on Friday (4).

Keep ReadingShow less
modi-trump-getty

Donald Trump and Narendra Modi hold a joint press conference in the East Room at the White House on February 13, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Explained: Impact of US tariffs on Indian exports

The United States has announced a 27 per cent reciprocal tariff on Indian goods entering the American market.

Industry experts have said these duties will pose challenges for Indian exports, though India's position remains more favourable than some of its competitors.

Keep ReadingShow less