Skip to content
Search
Please enter at least 3 characters.

Latest Stories

The Shamima conundrum is back to haunt UK

SHAMIMA BEGUM—one of the three east London schoolgirls who went to Syria to join ISIS—lost the first stage of her appeal against the government annulling her British citizenship.

Begum, 20, had left the UK in February 2015. She married a Dutch jihadi and lived under ISIS for nearly four years.


Last year, as the ‘caliphate’ fell, she was found in a Syrian refugee camp, nine months pregnant with her third baby. She had lost two children due to the malnutrition and disease.

Begum wanted to return to the UK, but infamously said she did not regret joining ISIS. After learning her case, Home Secretary Sajid Javid revoked Begum’s citizenship.

The third baby died within three weeks after birth. The issue came to a boil, but Javid stuck to his guns and said he would not “shy away from using those powers at my disposal to protect this country”.

Begum has been claiming that losing her British citizenship left her “stateless”, and vulnerable to torture and “real risk of death”.

The case was referred to a tribunal, led by Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) president Mrs Justice Elisabeth Laing, which, on Friday (7), ruled that Javid’s decision did not lead to Begum being stateless.

Representing the Home Office, Jonathan Glasson QC argued that Ms Begum “was a Bangladeshi citizen by descent, in accordance with Bangladeshi law, and so was not rendered stateless by the deprivation decision”.

Bangladesh, however, had said last year that Begum had “nothing to do” with the country and there was “no question” of giving her citizenship.

“She has never sought Bangladeshi citizenship and her parents are also British citizens,” said Bangladesh Foreign Minister Abdul Momen.

“The British government is responsible for her. They will have to deal with her.”

Momen also added that Bangladesh followed a “zero-tolerance policy” towards terrorism, and Begum would “have to face death penalty” if she were to be tried in the country.

Begum’s lawyer at that time, Tasnime Akunjee, too, had stated that “in no way is she Bangladesh’s problem”.

Begum’s current lawyer, Daniel Furner, said he would “immediately initiate an appeal” against the ruling “as a matter of exceptional urgency”.

Judge Doron Blum, who announced the tribunal’s verdict, said there had been no violation of the Home Office’s “extraterritorial human rights policy by exposing Ms Begum to a real risk of death or inhuman or degrading treatment”.

He enumerated the three “primary conclusions” the tribunal had arrived at:

“One, we conclude that the decision did not make her stateless.

“Two, we conclude that the decision did not breach the Secretary of State policy when he made decision one.

“The third is whether Ms Begum can have a fair and effective appeal. We accept that Ms Begum cannot have an effective appeal in her current circumstances but it does not follow that her appeal succeeds.”

Maya Foa, director of the human rights group Reprieve, said: “The court today found that the detention conditions of British nationals in north-east Syria constitute torture or cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment. It is rank hypocrisy for the government to abandon British families to torture, which it professes to categorically oppose. The only just solution is for the government to repatriate British families, and to try people in British courts if they have charges to answer”.

Clare Collier, advocacy director of the NGO Liberty, said: “The fact the government has left a young woman effectively stateless shows how little regard it holds for fundamental rights.

“Shamima Begum should not be banished—banishing people belongs in the dark ages, not 21st-century Britain. This case is just one example of how quickly ministers use citizenship-stripping when they could use other powers.

“It’s clear why they use these archaic banishments and that is to score political points and look tough on terrorism. It has nothing to do with making the public safe.

“In fact, this leaves us less safe as services are unable to conduct proper investigations that could help prevent young people, like Shamima, from entering terrorist circles in the future.”

Writer and playwright Aina Khan warned that UK was setting a “dangerous precedent” by not allowing Begum to return.

In a article for the Guardian, she wrote: “Somehow this child [Begum was 15 when she left for Syria] was groomed and radicalised, not in some far-away country bereft of democracy, but here on British soil…. Before condemning her we need to know how this naïve teenager was pushed in this direction. If she’d been sexually groomed at this age we would not be vilifying the victim.”

Khan asserted that Begum was “a product of Britain, not of Bangladesh—a country she has never visited”, and she “should be tried on British soil”.

More For You

NHS England to Restructure: Workforce to Be Reduced by 50%

The changes aim to cut costs and eliminate duplication with the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC). (Representational image: Getty)

Getty Images

NHS England to cut workforce by half in major restructuring

NHS ENGLAND will reduce its workforce from 13,000 to about 6,500 as part of a restructuring led by Health Secretary Wes Streeting.

The changes aim to cut costs and eliminate duplication with the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC), The Guardian reported.

Keep ReadingShow less
tanker-collission-reuters

Smoke and flames rise from a collision between oil tanker and a cargo ship off the northeastern coast of England. (Photo credit: Reuters)

Jet fuel tanker in flames after crash off England’s northeast coast

A TANKER carrying jet fuel for the US military caught fire after colliding with a container ship off the northeast coast of England on Monday. The impact caused multiple explosions, forcing both crews to evacuate.

The tanker, capable of carrying tens of thousands of tonnes of jet fuel, was at anchor when it was struck by a smaller container ship, rupturing its cargo tank and releasing fuel into the sea, according to its operator. The owner, Stena Bulk, confirmed the details.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jaishankar Concludes UK Visit: Key Discussions on Trade, Security, and Diaspora

Jaishankar wrapped up his visit with a tour of the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, hosted by foreign secretary David Lammy.

Jaishankar wraps up UK trip, talks focus on trade, security, and diaspora

INDIA's external affairs minister S Jaishankar has concluded his visit to the United Kingdom, reaffirming strong bilateral ties and adding fresh momentum to the comprehensive strategic partnership between the two countries, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) said on Monday.

Jaishankar wrapped up his visit with a tour of the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, hosted by foreign secretary David Lammy. He also attended a Tottenham versus Bournemouth football match at the stadium, which is in Lammy’s north London constituency.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bhim Kohli Murder Trial: Teenager's Admission of Guilt Revealed to Jury
The attack took place on 1 September last year in Franklin Park, Braunstone Town, Leicestershire. (Photo credit: Facebook)

Bhim Kohli murder: Teenager on trial said ‘I did it’, jury told

A 15-YEAR-OLD boy accused of killing an 80-year-old man in a Leicester park told police, “I had my reasons, but I did it,” a court heard.

The boy is charged with murdering Bhim Kohli at Franklin Park, Braunstone Town, in September last year. A 13-year-old girl, also on trial, is accused of manslaughter. Both were 14 and 12 at the time and cannot be named due to their ages.

Keep ReadingShow less
Mark-Carney-Reuters

Carney said he would stand up for Canada’s way of life and push back against American actions affecting trade. (Photo: Reuters)

Mark Carney vows to fight US trade war as Canada's next prime minister

MARK CARNEY, Canada's incoming prime minister, has pledged to take on the United States in an escalating trade dispute, vowing to defend the country’s interests against US president Donald Trump’s policies.

Speaking to supporters in Ottawa after being elected leader of the Liberal Party, Carney said he would stand up for Canada’s way of life and push back against American actions affecting trade.

Keep ReadingShow less