Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Trainee officer sacked over concerns about his hearing ability wins discrimination claim against Met Police

Shafi Karim was dismissed as his bosses felt he was ‘not capable of becoming a fully operational and effective police officer’ and his poor hearing could endanger himself and other officers.

Trainee officer sacked over concerns about his hearing ability wins discrimination claim against Met Police

A trainee officer sacked from the Met Police has won a discrimination claim against the force.

Shafi Karim worked as a probationary officer for five before he was dismissed in 2021 after his bosses raised concerns about his hearing abilities.

He was advised to use a Rogers Pen wireless microphone as he could not hear instructions but was made to pay about 30 per cent of the cost of the device and the insurance on it.

However, an employment tribunal in central London found that Scotland Yard should not have required Karim to pay his cost of the device and there was no justification for making him insure it.

Karim joined the Met Police as a probationary officer in 2015 having passed the initial hearing test. A year later, however, his training was paused as he struggled with 'hearing’ and he was referred to the occupational health department of the police force. But he was later posted to Finsbury Park before he became part of an emergency response team.

He complained of receiving 'feedback' if objects came too close to his hearing aids which he said turned police sirens into “torture”.

His dependence on the device also sometimes led him to awkward situations. Once its battery ran out during a police chase test and he had to stop to change it. On another occasion, messages had to be repeated for him. His colleagues also noticed he did not always hear when he was spoken to.

Karim was also told to complete role-play tests to prove his ability to work at an operational level, the tribunal heard.

His period of probation lasted much longer than the usual two years. He was finally dismissed after his bosses felt he was “not capable of becoming a fully operational and effective police officer” and his poor hearing could endanger himself and other officers.

The employment tribunal concluded Karim had been subjected to disability discrimination because of his dismissal.

Referring to the test he failed, employment tribunal judge Jillian Brown said there were less discriminatory ways of achieving “those legitimate aims”, including making reasonable adjustments.

The judge said the trainee officer was put at a substantial disadvantage.

Brown said the police force “should never have required” Karim to pay part of the cost of the hearing aid kit.

Observing that it was the Met was “completely unjustified” for requiring him to insure the hearing aids, the judge said Scotland Yard should have insured the device “in the same way as all other equipment.”

But the tribunal dismissed his other contention that the Met made a 'stereotypical assumption' that his hearing impairment 'rendered him incapable' of doing his job.

It will decide on the compensation at a later date.

More For You

Sunita-Williams-Reuters

Sunita Williams was part of the SpaceX Crew-9 mission and had been stranded in space for over nine months. (Photo: Reuters)

Reuters)

India looks amazing from space, says Sunita Williams

NASA astronaut Sunita Williams described India as "amazing" from space and expressed her intention to visit her "father's home country" to share her experiences on space exploration.

Speaking at a press conference on Monday, she responded to a question about how India appeared from space and the possibility of collaboration with the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO).

Keep ReadingShow less
british-muslims-iStock

The study noted that this identification was not due to any doctrinal obligation but was influenced by the perception that many Muslims do not feel fully accepted as British. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Majority of British Muslims identify by faith first, study finds

A STUDY by the Institute for the Impact of Faith in Life (IIFL) has found that most British Muslims identify primarily with their religion rather than their nationality.

The research, based on a survey of 815 British Muslim adults by Whitestone Insight, revealed that 71 per cent of respondents identified as Muslim first, while 27 per cent identified as British, English, or Scottish first.

Keep ReadingShow less
Car Tax Changes: EV Owners Now Required to Pay for the First Time

Owners of electric vehicles registered on or after 1 April 2025 will pay £10 for the first year, followed by the standard VED rate of £195 from the second year. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Car tax changes take effect: EV owners to pay for first time

FROM today, 1 April 2025, electric cars, vans, and motorcycles in the UK will be subject to Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) for the first time.

The change, introduced in the 2022 Autumn Statement by former Conservative Chancellor Jeremy Hunt, aims to make motoring taxation fairer.

Keep ReadingShow less
scotland-minimum-wages-iStock

Full-time workers on the National Living Wage will receive an annual pay increase of £1,400 in real terms. (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

Wage increase takes effect for thousands of workers in Scotland

HUNDREDS of thousands of workers in Scotland will see a pay increase as new National Living Wage and National Minimum Wage rates take effect from Tuesday.

The changes will benefit approximately 220,000 people, according to STV News.

Keep ReadingShow less
uk-energy-bill-iStock

Water bills, energy prices, and council tax are rising, while the minimum wage has also increased (Representational image: iStock)

iStock

April bill increases put financial strain on single parents

A RANGE of essential household bills are increasing from April, with Citizens Advice warning that single parents will be among the hardest hit.

Water bills, energy prices, and council tax are rising, while the minimum wage has also increased, BBC reported.

Keep ReadingShow less