Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Faith leaders weigh in on ethics and impact of assisted dying bill

Currently, assisting or encouraging another person to take their own life is an offence in England, Wales and Northern Ireland with a maximum prison sentence of 14 years.

Faith leaders weigh in on ethics and impact of assisted dying bill
The debate over assisted dying legislation raises critical questions about patient autonomy and the role of medical professionals in end-of-life care

ASIAN faith leaders and doctors are divided on whether there should be a law change to allow assisted dying in the UK.

A bill to legalise helping someone to die in Scotland was published at Holyrood by the Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP Liam McArthur.


McArthur’s bill, which will offer terminally ill adults help to end their lives, is set to be debated by politicians in the autumn and voted on next year.

Currently, assisting or encouraging another person to take their own life is an offence in England, Wales and Northern Ireland with a maximum prison sentence of 14 years. In Scotland, helping someone to kill themselves could lead to prosecution for crimes including murder and culpable homicide.

At the end of July, BBC reported that former Labour justice secretary Lord Falconer introduced a bill in the House of Lords under which terminally ill adults with six months or fewer to live can get medical help to end their own lives.

Health secretary Wes Streeting told the BBC’s Radio 4 Today programme he was “uncharacteristically undecided” on the subject, but said the “time had come” for a debate on the matter.

Sikh and Hindu groups have suggested assisted dying should be allowed in some circumstances, while Muslim groups say Islam opposes any form of euthanasia.

Lord Rami Ranger CBE, a businessman and chairman of the British Sikh Association, told Eastern Eye: “I support assisted end-of-life once doctors and loved ones have confirmed that the person has no chance of recovery and his or her condition will continue to deteriorate further.

“It is important that we do not prolong the suffering of individual and the family once there is no hope of a person ever getting better and their condition will continue to persist or deteriorate with time.”

When he was Labour leader, Sir Keir Starmer said he was “committed” to allowing a vote on decriminalising assisted dying if the party won the general election. In July he said MPs would have a free vote on the issue.

Downing Street previously said it would be up to parliament to decide whether to debate assisted dying again.

Dr Salman Waqar, president of The British Islamic Medical Association, said his organisation is “extremely concerned” about proposals to legalise assisted suicide and euthanasia.

He told Eastern Eye: “Complex physical and emotional suffering can be effectively managed by palliative care professionals, without shortening people’s lives.

“Assisted dying may reduce communities’ trust in health services, and goes against the professional conduct based on the ethical principle ‘first, do no harm’. Resources, instead, should be focused into improving end-of-life care quality and access, which is a particular concern for ethnic minority communities.”

Shaykh Dr Umar Al-Qadri, of the Irish Muslim Peace & Integration Council, said in Islam “the unambiguous prohibition against suicide or assisted dying is unequivocally expressed in the Holy Qu’ran”.

The last vote in Parliament on this issue was in 2015, when the Commons decided against changing the law by 330 votes to 118. Meanwhile, The Isle of Man moved closer to introducing assisted dying after a historic vote in May.

A bid to prevent NHS staff from having a role in assisted dying was rejected by members of the House of Keys.

Rajnish Kashyap, general secretary of the Hindu Council UK, said: “Some may argue that a managed death primarily affects the physical body and does not directly impact the eternal essence of the individual. The religion embraces the concepts of karma, the law of cause and effect, dharma, the righteous path or duty, and ahimsa, a commitment to non-violence, which may conflict with a managed death.

“Hindu scriptures provide examples where suicide is recommended or permitted under specific circumstances, such as restitution for crimes or to avoid extreme shame or suffering.

While these instances may not directly relate to euthanasia, they do offer important precedents for considering end-oflife decisions within a moral framework.

“Ultimately, discussions about managing death in Hinduism require careful reflection on these philosophical principles and their application to specific situations of suffering and end-of-life care. Decisions are, therefore, personal after due contemplation of the situation.”

MPs are also divided on whether England should follow Scotland’s lead and consider a law change.

Prior to the July election, Rupa Huq, Labour MP for Ealing Central and Acton, said: “When it comes to abortion, I am very pro-choice, but last time we voted on this subject [assisted dying] I actively abstained — voted yes and no — and was relieved that the status quo was upheld.

“With the Hippocratic oath and other things, we are just massively torn on this one, despite the opinion polls.”

Labour MP Sir Stephen Timms said: “It seems to me that legalising assisted dying would impose a terrible dilemma on frail people, elderly people and others when they are at the most vulnerable point in their lives, especially on conscientious frail people who do not want to die but do not want to be a burden.

“I do not think there is any way to avoid imposing that dilemma. The NHS should be there to protect those people.

“It is reported that in Oregon since 2017, over half the applicants for assisted dying have applied not because they want to die but because they feel like a burden.

“The next time we have a government committed to austerity, the temptation to cut health service costs by allowing people to choose to end their lives in a wider set of circumstances, instead of funding their care, would, I fear, be irresistible.”

More For You

CSK vs RCB

CSK and RCB-tune in for this blockbuster clash between two IPL heavyweights

Getty Images

IPL 2025 - CSK vs RCB: Chennai and Bengaluru's clash of titans

The Indian Premier League (IPL) is back with another highly anticipated encounter as Chennai Super Kings (CSK) lock horns with Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) in the 8th match of the 2025 season. The match will take place at the iconic MA Chidambaram Stadium in Chennai on March 28th at 7:30 PM IST. Both teams are coming off strong wins in their previous matches and are eager to extend their winning streaks, making this clash one that fans won’t want to miss.

Team analysis: Chennai Super Kings (CSK)

CSK, one of the most successful franchises in IPL history, comes into this game with confidence after a thrilling victory over Mumbai Indians. Although the chase wasn’t entirely smooth, CSK managed to pull off a win with 4 wickets in hand. Their bowling unit, led by the young sensation Noor Ahmad, was instrumental in restricting Mumbai to a modest total of 155/9. Noor’s outstanding spell of 4 wickets for just 18 runs earned him the well-deserved Man of the Match title, while Khaleel Ahmed also chipped in with 3 wickets.

Keep ReadingShow less
Streeting: Health deal signals new era in UK-India ties

Foreign Office minister Catherine West, health secretary Wes Streeting and equalities minister Seema Malhotra during the Holi Reception in London.

Streeting: Health deal signals new era in UK-India ties

THE recent health and life sciences agreement between the UK and India will strengthen cooperation on healthcare innovation and security in both countries, health secretary Wes Streeting said.

Speaking at the Holi reception organised by the India All-Party Parliamentary Group and the 1928 Institute in London on Monday (24), he added that the contribution of British Indians has been pivotal in the growth of the NHS since its inception in 1948, and a robust partnership between the two nations will ensure we have a healthcare provider 'fit for the future'.

Keep ReadingShow less
Renée Zellweger Joins Only Murders in the Building Season 5 Cast

Renée Zellweger joins the cast of Only Murders in the Building Season 5, bringing more star power to the hit series

Getty Images

Renée Zellweger joins ‘Only Murders in the Building’ season 5 with an expanded star-studded cast

The Oscar-winning actress joins Steve Martin, Selena Gomez, and Martin Short in Hulu’s hit mystery-comedy for an exciting new season.

Renée Zellweger is the latest Hollywood star to join Hulu's hit mystery-comedy Only Murders in the Building for its fifth season. The two-time Academy Award winner will share the screen with series regulars Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez, adding to the show’s already impressive line-up of guest stars.

Keep ReadingShow less
british-steel-iStock

An aerial view of Steel Plant Industry in Scunthorpe. (Photo: iStock)

British Steel to shut blast furnaces, up to 2,700 jobs at risk

BRITISH STEEL, owned by Chinese group Jingye, confirmed on Thursday that it will shut down its blast furnaces and steelmaking operations in England, attributing the decision to market challenges, tariffs, and rising environmental costs.

The closures, first proposed in late 2023, could lead to the loss of up to 2,700 jobs at the company’s main UK site in Scunthorpe, northern England, according to sources familiar with the matter.

Keep ReadingShow less