Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

US lawyer apologises for creating fake cases using ChatGPT

At present, there has been no immediate response from OpenAI, the organisation behind ChatGPT, regarding Schwartz’s unfortunate incident

US lawyer apologises for creating fake cases using ChatGPT

A US lawyer's decision to employ ChatGPT, an advanced language model, for the preparation of a crucial court filing has led to an astonishing turn of events.

The artificial intelligence programme generated fabricated cases and rulings, causing immense embarrassment to the attorney involved.


Steven Schwartz, a lawyer based in New York, issued an apology to a judge this week after realising that the brief he had submitted contained false information generated by the OpenAI chatbot.

"I simply had no idea that ChatGPT was capable of fabricating entire case citations or judicial opinions, especially in a manner that appeared authentic," Schwartz wrote in a court filing.

The incident took place during the proceedings of a civil case at the Manhattan federal court, where Roberto Mata is suing the Colombian airline Avianca.

Mata alleges that he sustained an injury when a metal serving plate struck his leg during a flight from El Salvador to New York in August 2019.

After the airline's lawyers asked the court to dismiss the case, Schwartz filed a response that claimed to cite more than half a dozen decisions to support why the litigation should proceed.

They included Petersen v. Iran Air, Varghese v. China Southern Airlines and Shaboon v. Egyptair.

The Varghese case even included dated internal citations and quotes.

However, there was one major problem: neither Avianca's attorneys nor the presiding judge, P. Kevin Castel could find the cases.

Schwartz was compelled to acknowledge that ChatGPT had fabricated all the information provided in the response.

"The court is presented with an unprecedented circumstance," judge Castel wrote last month.

"Six of the submitted cases appear to be bogus judicial decisions with bogus quotes and bogus internal citations," he added.

In response to the situation, the judge issued an order summoning Schwartz and his law partner to appear before the court, to face possible sanctions.

In a filing submitted on Tuesday (06) prior to the hearing, Schwartz expressed his sincere apologies to the court, acknowledging his profound regret for the significant error he had made.

He explained that his introduction to ChatGPT came from his college-educated children, and this incident marked the first occasion he had utilised the tool in his professional capacity.

"At the time that I performed the legal research in this case, I believed that ChatGPT was a reliable search engine. I now know that was incorrect," he wrote.

Schwartz added that it "was never my intention to mislead the court."

Since its launch in late last year, ChatGPT has gained worldwide attention for its remarkable capability to generate human-like content, ranging from essays and poems to engaging conversations based on minimal prompts.

At present, there has been no immediate response from OpenAI, the organisation behind ChatGPT, regarding Schwartz's unfortunate incident.

The story initially surfaced in The New York Times.

Schwartz, along with his firm, Levidow, Levidow & Oberman, expressed their distress over the media coverage, highlighting the sense of being subjected to public ridicule.

In a statement, Schwartz acknowledged the profound embarrassment caused on both personal and professional fronts, recognising that the articles regarding the incident would remain accessible for years to come.

He further assured the court that the situation had served as a valuable lesson, vowing to never repeat such an error in the future.

(AFP)

More For You

ve-day-getty

VE Day 80 street parties, picnics and community get togethers are being encouraged to take place across the country as part of the Great British Food Festival. (Photo: Getty Images)

Public invited to attend VE Day 80 procession and flypast

THE 80th anniversary of Victory in Europe (VE) Day will be marked with a military procession in London on May 5.

The event will include over 1,300 members of the Armed Forces, youth groups, and uniformed services marching from Parliament Square to Buckingham Palace.

Keep ReadingShow less
Knife crimes

Knife-enabled crimes include cases where a blade or sharp instrument was used to injure or threaten, including where the weapon was not actually seen.

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Knife crime in London accounts for a third of national total: ONS

KNIFE-RELATED crime in London made up almost a third of all such offences recorded in England and Wales in 2024, with the Metropolitan Police logging 16,789 incidents, according to figures released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) on Thursday.

This amounts to one offence every 30 minutes in the capital and represents 31 per cent of the 54,587 knife-enabled crimes reported across England and Wales last year. The total number marks a two per cent rise from 53,413 offences in 2023.

Keep ReadingShow less
Starmer and Modi

Starmer and Modi shake hands during a bilateral meeting in the sidelines of the G20 summit at the Museum of Modern Art in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Brazil, on November 18, 2024.

Getty Images

Starmer calls Modi over Kashmir attack; expresses condolences

PRIME MINISER Keir Starmer spoke to Indian prime minister Narendra Modi on Friday morning following the deadly attack in Kashmir’s Pahalgam region that killed 26 people on Tuesday.

According to a readout from 10 Downing Street, Starmer said he was horrified by the devastating terrorist attack and expressed deep condolences on behalf of the British people to those affected, their loved ones, and the people of India. The two leaders agreed to stay in touch.

Keep ReadingShow less
 Post Office Horizon

A Post Office van parked outside the venue for the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry at Aldwych House on January 11, 2024 in London, England. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Post Office spent £600m to keep Horizon despite plans to replace it: Report

THE POST OFFICE has spent more than £600 million of public funds to continue using the Horizon IT system, according to a news report.

Despite deciding over a decade ago to move away from the software, the original 1999 contract with Fujitsu prevented the Post Office from doing so, as it did not own the core software code, a BBC investigation shows.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pahalgam attack: Prayer meet held at Indian mission in London

The prayer meet was led by Indian High Commissioner to the UK Vikram Doraiswami

Pahalgam attack: Prayer meet held at Indian mission in London

Mahesh Liloriya

A PRAYER meet was held at the Gandhi Hall in the High Commission of India in London on Thursday (24) to pay respects to the victims of the Pahalgam terrorist attack.

Chants of ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ rang out at the event which was led by Indian High Commissioner to the UK Vikram Doraiswami.

Keep ReadingShow less