Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Why the UK police force fails to improve diversity

Why the UK police force fails to improve diversity

THERE is a popular saying that madness is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result to materialise.

The police in Britain have failed to reflect the diversity of the community they serve and have failed on Sir Robert Peel’s founding description of policing, which was, “the police are the public and the public are the police; the police being only members of the public who are paid to give full time attention to duties which are incumbent on every citizen in the interests of community welfare and existence.”


What is going wrong and what can the police do? The Home Affairs Select Committee Report  released last Friday (30) on race and policing focuses on evidence and the lack of progress and pulls no punches. It has been 22 years since the Macpherson report into why the white murders of Stephen Lawrence were not identified and prosecuted, with the blame down to “institutional racism”.

The police continue to rely on strategy, but fail to deliver effective action plans and bring about a change. The Black Lives Matter has added to the scrutiny police in England and Wales are receiving and their record on race examined.

No longer will warm words be sufficient; results are what communities demand. The police hierarchy, as well as the Home Office, are serial recipients of improvement reports on race and police, among them the Scarman Inquiry,the Morris Report, the CRE Report, the Macpherson Report, the Lammy Report.

Each and every time the reports say the same thing – the key metrics on recruitment, promotion, retention, stop and search, discipline are disproportionate against people of colour.

LEAD Comment Dal Babu Dalwardin Babu byline pic DAL BABU OBE

When challenged, the police will wring their hands and say that race is a priority. Martin Hewitt of the National Council of Chief Officers said, “Our policing style is based on legitimacy and our legitimacy is based on the trust and confidence of all communities.

“It is a fact that the trust and confidence levels within the black community are 20 per cent, or thereabouts, lower than the white communities, and that impacted on the trust and confidence for us to do what we do as a service.”

He goes onto to say, “So that means trust and confidence in terms of when we’re out and about, doing policing out on the streets and policing communities, as we need all our communities to have that trust and confidence.

“It’s only with that trust and confidence and legitimacy that people come forward, people report crimes, people become witnesses, people work with us, and … that trust and confidence leads to young black men and women saying, ‘I’m prepared to go and become a police officer.’”

So will this latest report make any difference or will we see the latest Home Office Select Committee report gather dust?

I gave evidence to the Home Affairs Select Committee in 2016 and made a number of recommendations, including holding individual chief constables to account, national performance objectives on race and equality and regular scrutiny by the Home Affairs Select Committee on race and diversity progress by the police.

My recommendations were based on my lived experience of the police leaders who were paying lip service to diversity, but rarely acting. That is why I suggested that police leaders were personally held to account and the progress or lack of it scrutinised by parliament in my recommendations.

Sadly, there was no political will or indeed police leadership desire to introduce measures that would work. The most disturbing result is that confidence in policing continues to wane in black and Asian communities; with a gap of 20 per cent between white and ethnic minority communities.

It was no surprise my recommendations were not implemented; instead, we have another report.

Unfortunately, successive home secretaries, chief constables and more recently police and crime commissioners have paid mere lip service to race and policing, but remained silent on the results.

It is only when we see leaders removed for their diversity failure will we see results. Despite these failures, however, damehoods and knighthoods are lavished on these failing organisations. I will leave you with an example of why I feel pessimistic.

The National Crime Agency – the UK’s answer to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) in the US – was set up in 2013 and had the chance to reflect diversity right from the start.

Today, only one of the 15 senior leaders is from an ethnic minority background.

More For You

‘It’s time for UK-India ties to focus on a joint growth story’
Kanishka Narayan (centre) with fellow visiting British MPs, Rajasthan chief minister Bhajan Lal Sharma (left) and other officials

‘It’s time for UK-India ties to focus on a joint growth story’

FOUR months since my election to parliament, I had the opportunity to join my parliamentary colleagues on a delegation to India, visiting Delhi and Jaipur for conversations with our Indian counterparts, business leaders and academics.

I went to make the case for Indian investment in my constituency and across the UK.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Ministers must unveil vision for bridging societal divides’
(From left) Professor Ted Cantle, Sunder Katwala, Sara Khan and John Denham at the event

‘Ministers must unveil vision for bridging societal divides’

“SOCIAL cohesion is not the absence of riots.”

John Denham put that central point pithily at the ‘After the Riots’ cohesion summit last week.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Policy reforms should not halt development’
Environmental policies and grid delays are slowing the delivery of new homes

‘Policy reforms should not halt development’

SINCE 2006, Summix has specialised in securing planning for strategic land and urban, mixed-use regeneration projects.

Working with our development partners, we have successfully delivered more than 6,000 homes in the UK. We continue to bring forward strategic residential development sites with over 18,000 homes in our current pipeline, including a new settlement for 10,000 homes at Worcestershire Parkway, which was recently referenced by Chancellor Rachel Reeves in her inaugural speech.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Ethnic disparities in IVF success rate highlight access challenges’
According to a recent report, IVF birth rate for Asian patients is 24 per cent, lagging behind 32 per cent for white patients

‘Ethnic disparities in IVF success rate highlight access challenges’

WITH nearly 30 years as an NHS consultant and as a British Asian woman, I am acutely aware of the unique challenges ethnic minority patients face in healthcare, especially on their journey towards parenthood.

This week, National Fertility Awareness Week shines a critical light on the psychological impact of infertility in minority ethnic communities. It is time to confront the barriers and stigmas contributing to inequalities in IVF access and outcomes for BAME patients, and the ways these amplify the mental challenges in what is often already a highly emotional and personal journey.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Stamp out racism to secure the future of NHS’
Many International Medical Graduates report experiencing racism but are reluctant to report it

‘Stamp out racism to secure the future of NHS’

THE General Medical Council’s [GMC] chief executive has recognised discrimination in medicine is, “persistent and pernicious.”

This is an essential first step: ethnic minority doctors are subject to disproportionate GMC complaints and referrals. Although the GMC’s recent equality, diversity and inclusion report highlighted progress towards closing this gap, we can’t afford to ignore this issue. Racism in the NHS must be stamped out if we are to create a system that works for everyone.

Keep ReadingShow less